-
March 2024 by Channing Delph
Local gem. Pizza is one of the best around and worth waiting around for. Sabatino also has a secret menu that is the hidden charm of this place. The pesto pasta with Mushrooms I had show just a drop of the culinary skills this dude has - eggplant rollatini is wow. Thanks guys.
-
February 2024 by Emily Guerrero
EXCELLENT ALWAYS! Sabatino’s never disappoints, best pizza hands down. My family and I have traveled from Connecticut for this pizza!!! Not to mention Sabatino himself is a great person, always love seeing him! Kids who work here are always pleasant, professional, and polite. It’s always a great experience!
-
January 2024 by V James
Loved their pizza! Great crust, flavorful topping.
-
January 2024 by Rob R
Great pizza. Great food. Highly recommend.
-
December 2023 by Victoria Jenkins
DONT EAT HERE! I ATE/ CHEWED A LONG PIECE OF HAIR! I then called and complained and the guy tonight 12/10/23 at 7:07 told me: no one has 16” blond hair there. I said wow. I’m a black woman with 8” hair at the longest! I even suggest that I’ll take another pizza or a refund and he said there’s nothing he can do for me. This is the First time ordering from here . So I first called 5:54 to see if since it’s Sunday, they were still accepting orders. They said yes so I ordered from door dash. I got a personal size pizza with sausage for 33 bucks before Door dash charges including delivery and too it was 20 bucks. Horrible experience and I will upload pictures of me and the hair! Customer service and product 0 out of 10! I took one with it sprea out and one bunched up where it had more of a red tint at that point.
-
December 2023 by Michael Thomas
My dad and I have been looking for a great pizza shop here in Jersey and Sabatinos did not disappoint. Made us feel like we were back in LI NY. Great job guys!
-
October 2023 by Joe Rod
Went Thurs with the guys from work and the food was great had wings special was good and great deal and the staff was amazing! The lady with the pretty blue eyes pretty sure her name was Dayna went above and beyond to make sure we were happy she is a asset to that place!
-
October 2023 by M
Great specialty pies. White pizza with balsamic is terrific. But the wait simply isn’t worth it. I have moved on.
-
October 2023 by Kristopher Butcher
An order of Mozz Stix is 5 pieces per order.
-
October 2023 by Mahasin Phillips
It’s the garlic knots for me!!! The food is always made fresh and delicious! Excellent service too!
-
October 2023 by Daria Bialik
The best.
-
October 2023 by Nicola Suraci
Ms. Dayna at Sabatinos was so kind to me and gave me the most delicious garlic knots for half the price. This place has the kindest most caring people 10/10 recommend this place!
-
October 2023 by M. P.
It’s the garlic knots for me!!! The food is always made fresh and delicious! Excellent service too!
-
September 2023 by dylan lantigua
TERRIBLE COMMUNICATION ! HOURS OF OPERATION ARE NEVER UPDATED ONLINE, PLACE NEVER SEEMS OPEN ON THE WEEKEND, AND MANAGEMENT DOES A GREAT JOB OF KEEPING GUESTS ON THEIR TOES. SECOND WEEK IN A ROW WHERE WE GO GO TO PLACE AN ORDER, AND NO ONE IS THERE. SIGN SAYS OPEN, WEBSITE SAYS OPEN, BUT NO ONE IS THERE. WHO IS CLOSED ON A SUNDAY AT 4PM DURING FIRST WEEK OF FOOTBALL SUNDAY. GOT GREAT PIZZA ELSEWHERE.
-
September 2023 by Priti S.
Their pizza is great. But do not pay until you've received your order. I was told they didn't have an item, offered a substitution, which I was happy to take. But the kid at the door could not tell me what else I could substitute it with so I didn't know what to say. He later said they would just refund the item. I was never refunded. If I go back will make sure to pay in cash or just not pay until I get my order. It's unfortunate because I've ordered a lot from here, but this experience has definitely left a sour taste and it seems like others have had some similar experiences. Great pizza. Poor customer service.