10AM - 5PM
595 River Rd, Fair Haven“If I can give this store 10 stars I would! This store is MAGICAL! I met the owner “Margaret” she was wonderful! They have EVERYTHING you need in this store and they even gift wrap! The staff was delightful as well and very helpful and kind. This is my go to store now and I encourage anyone reading this review to GO! You will NOT be disappointed!”
10AM - 5:30PM
62a Main Ave, Ocean Grove“Any 0 star review on this place is an absolute lie. it was a great selection for a small store like this! Graham was incredibly friendly and even let us look into unopened cases! He was very helpful in what we were looking for, and as we ventured deeper into the store we found more! Definitely coming back! Thanks Graham!”
10AM - 6PM
980 Shrewsbury Ave, Tinton Falls“I’ll give it 5 stars bc I like the stuff. It’s quality consignment. But the older woman is just awful. No personality and rude. She’s lucky it’s a good store because if it based off her personality and service it would have been shut down.”
9:30AM - 6PM
310 NJ-36 #24, West Long Branch“The employee that checked me out was so nice, I wish every store was like that. As we all know some things are worth more than $5 & some are worth less, you have to pick and choose them.”
“Got a squishy toy that I saw some coworkers playing with. Looks like a dot candy and good for hand pain and hand exercises. Cool place and seems to have a bunch of stuff that adults may like too like Pokémon cards and weird pens.”