-
January 2024 by Danielle J.
Had brunch at the Gotham Diner on Thursday morning with my family. The diner is convenient from the road and was clean with a typical NJ diner vibe.Our server was lovely and attentive. At the end she apologized for not being able to give us more attention as they were understaffed but we didn't even notice! I ordered the chicken soup on recommendation from my sister and it was so worth it! Delicious! My kids had the pancakes with sides of fruit, my husband has an omelet as did my sister. And I had egg whites with a side of sausage. Everything was cooked well, and came out hot. Definitely will go back!
-
December 2023 by Mufti A.
My first and last time here. I've had several diners in the area in the last couple months and this was my least favorite experience. Food was bland and cold. Got the 2 egg platter. Home fries were unseasoned. Never got my toasts. The ambience was also very negative. Place was dark and broody. I understand it's called Gotham city diner but tone off the batman theme. Cause he sure ain't coming here to eat. The server was nice but the rest do the staff were not. Won't be returning. Recommend if you're reading his, drive a bit south to saddle brook diner
-
December 2023 by Jen W.
I've wanted to go to Gotham for 2 years now, seeing it every time I got on the highway, but never had time to stop in. Being my last Friday in the Fair Lawn area, it was the perfect opportunity. We got there around 8:30am. Only a couple of tables were seated. Not busy at all. We were given two menus. The regular menu, and the specials. We both decided on the special. Eggs, home fries, choice of meat, and toast with a Coffee for $10.50. The coffee came out first and was refilled a couple of times during our meal. It was OK coffee, hot enough on a cold morning. I ordered two eggs over medium, home fries, ham and rye toast. Dunked everything in ketchup, and had a solid diner meal. I did like the sausage links better than the ham though. The restaurant itself is neat. Lots of New York City touches. Make sure to look up as you explore. Subway tiles and painted signs are interesting. The meal didn't blow our socks off, but it was a great early morning breakfast in a cozy atmosphere.
-
October 2023 by Hailey M.
Left a tip of a specified amount and they charged my card almost double the tip that I left. Predatory business practice and uncontroverted thievery. Puts a disgusting taste in my mouth. I will not return to this establishment.
-
October 2023 by Ed M.
I've been to Gotham City Diner 3 times.First time, Though the food was good, there were NATS flying around and made the xepeieience lackluster and not a good one.Second time, though the food was good, the service was terrible. I did send my plate back due to the Burger not being cooked correctly and the fries were cold and undercooked.Third and Last time, I went there for dinner and I ordered their well advertised 24/7 breakfast special.There was no special, actually cost more than morning prices. I ordered 2 over easy with Corn Beef hash.The waitress had never heard of Corn Beef hash and I had to show her on the menu where it was.When it finally came, the eggs were dried Up and the Corn Beef hash was over cooked. I sent it back to the kitchen. When it arrived again, the eggs were ok, but the Corn Beef hash was slimy. I could not believe that they would serve it. It seemed old and looked nasty!I will never go back there!!! You should not either.
-
August 2023 by Oi W.
As a NY'r, this was a fun restaurant. Seeing the old signs for the NYC subway. Shea Staduim The service was great!The food was just ok. There is nothing to rush back for.Chicken Wings 2 ways, Spicy Buffalo or Carolina Dry Rub. Buffalo was the better of the 2, but it was just ok. The dry rub was strangely sweet...Moderna OmelettePortobello mushroom, fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes & basil - the mushrooms were like pickled or something, it was sweetly sour... not enough sun-dried tomatoes, however, it clashed with the mushrooms...
-
June 2023 by Cat M.
What you'd expect from a typical dinner. Food is good and fresh. Grabbed a Tuscan panini with curly fries. Went for an early evening dinner and food came out quickly. Service was friendly. Diner is subway or nyc themed.
-
April 2023 by Doreen V.
When in Jersey, we try to hit the Diners for at least one meal. Gotham City Diner is one we had not been to. Classic (meaning) - good theme in decor , good coffee, mug always refilled, book like menu, & good breakfast at a decent price (remember, what use to be under $10 is now about $12-18 for breakfast). Food was served hot, quickly, very fresh & tasty. Our server was friendly, bubbly & checking in constantly. My breakfast was the classic 2 egg platter. I ordered 2 eggs over medium, home fries, pork roll & rye toast. Everything came out cooked perfectly. My husband ordered a short stack of pancakes with chorizo sausage. Amazing taste to both items. If we are coming through this part of the state, I am sure we will stop again.
-
January 2023 by Joyce B.
I had breakfast with my family here after church. Wait time was about 1 minute to get seated. They immediately took our drink order. My cousin got a chefs salad and it was HUGE. I tried the Oreo pancakes. They were okay and my mother had the corn beef and eggs. Tried some of that and it was good. The vibe was nice. Waitress was so attentive and friendly. I noticed several different TVs around the restaurant for customers to watch. I wish it was more marvel themed
-
December 2022 by Rafael Guerrero Morales
ATM is out of service. ?
-
November 2022 by Chandler B.
Went for lunch today with the family and it was awful. This is the Hummus wrap. $16 for a tablespoon of hummus. Brought out the wrong fries, forgot chicken on a Greek salad and waitress was clueless. Manager said "it was my fault because Greek salad doesn't come with chicken". We know this that's why we ordered "Greek salad with grilled chicken" Place was a ghost town. Quality used to be good. I guess they just stopped caring. I don't care either we will just go somewhere else. Salads are $17+. Inflation hit this place hard.
-
November 2022 by Allia K.
We always enjoy going to this diner. It is one of our local but good diners! We always go with kids and they are always so patient. This particular trip we were there with 5 kids and the stuff was very friendly. I almost always get the Benedict because they actually make them right! If you haven't tried this location yet, it's a must!
-
October 2022 by Nicholas G.
If there was a picture of a diner in the dictionary it would be a picture of the Gotham City Diner. As standard as you can get. You know exactly what you are going to get here. Good comfort food and I almost always order breakfast because thats the best at diners. Omelette any time of day! The muffin was also solid. Plenty of tables and booths as well. 3 stars is exactly where its at. Maybe 3.5.
-
August 2022 by Surelyne L.
One of the better diners in the area. Burgers are huge and well made. My hot open roast beef sandwich was huge and excellent with the bread deeply buried in a mountain of roast beef. I don't think I even got to it! Our server was very attentive. Highly recommend!