-
February 2024 by Helen Levins
We had an amazing experience at McGarry’s. We wanted a wedding band for my husband with a simple Celtic knot. Tracy showed us a number of options from a jewelry company she works with and none were quite right, so she was able to make the ring herself, showing us renderings, and letting us try on different metals and widths. We couldn’t be happier with the end result, which was made quickly and for a reasonable price, especially considering that it was custom made. We tried other jewelers before coming here and this was by far the best experience.
-
June 2023 by Alexa Scherer
Love this place as well as the people!
-
June 2023 by Lauren Goldstein
I dropped my engagement ring off here to be polished before my wedding day. It looks incredible!! They did a great job and handled It with the utmost care. I always enjoy talking with Tracy when I go in there. She genuinely cares about her customers.
-
May 2023 by Lauren Volin-Kelder
I dropped my engagement ring off here to be polished before my wedding day. It looks incredible!! They did a great job and handled It with the utmost care. I always enjoy talking with Tracy when I go in there. She genuinely cares about her customers.
-
March 2023 by Tracie Miller (Broker/Owner-STS)
Tracy is a genius. I completely forgot to write a review after she custom designed a gorgeous piece for me years ago. I'm going back to her to custom design my engagement ring. Much love! 10/10!!
-
December 2022 by Bryan _Hectic
Great customer service. My fiance and I brought in her engagement ring to be repairs after a stone fell out, they got it repaired in a timely manner and at a fair price. Ended up buying our wedding bands here too!
-
December 2022 by Megan Migioia
Just an overall really awesome experience. My boyfriend and I went in with no plan to start our engagement ring process. I knew I wanted a gem other than a diamond, and Tracy was so patient with me as she sourced gems (so cool). I felt she was very honest, listened to what I wanted and showed me the different options. My boyfriend then took over and completed the ring design. He popped the question yesterday and I can't stop staring at my ring! I'll be stopping in to show Tracy and plan on using McGarry's for all my jewelry needs going forward.
-
October 2022 by Danielle Hayduchok
Tracy and McGarry's Jewelers are absolutely the best! My husband and I went to the store to first resize and insure my engagement ring and then returned to buy our wedding rings. Tracy helped create an one-of-a-kind ring that fits around my engagement ring and matches my style and the engagement ring perfectly. Everything was completed on time and everyone there is so professional and kind. Thank you, McGarry's!!!
-
October 2022 by Hannah C
I went to this Jeweler looking for a person to adjust a very important ring I had (not a big ask). The jeweler was not there at the time, so the clerk took my number to verify the times he would be there in the future so that I didn't have to leave the ring at the shop without me. They called me that night, as promised, and left a detailed voicemail about the jeweler's schedule. Unfortunately, I got so busy and wasn't able to go for another two months. I finally was able to stop by and really needed the ring adjusting at this point, but was with my two kids, so a little hesitant to go in as we all know young children in a Jewelry shop sometimes don't combine well :) I explained who I was, and another person went to the back with the ring. I looked at some other rings while waiting for about 5 minutes. The original woman who had called me came out, with the ring already adjusted, smiling remembering exactly who I was. She told me I was all set and insisted I didn't need to pay! But, I had found such a cute well priced 35-dollar ring, and silly me had left my wallet in my car. I offered my phone to the woman as I really wanted to buy the ring because it was dainty, beautiful gold with small diamonds, and matched my style. She insisted I don't need to do that, and even offered to watch my kids, while I ran to the car. I came back in and she offered my children lollipops, she had asked their ages, and remembered their names by the end of this 10-minute interaction, and was just so incredibly kind despite them opening and closing a few ring boxes amidst the wait. Not once did she seem bothered at all. Interactions such as these are the reason I love to support local businesses. The customer service, and kindness this woman emitted, make the world just a little brighter. Thank you to the staff at McGarry's! My new ring is doing amazing under my heavy-use circumstances, and my old one fits perfectly now. I'll definitely be back, and would recommend them 100x over!
-
September 2022 by Teresa Bramble
Helpful, friendly & quite a selection at any price range. Very happy they were able to fixed my necklace overnight.
-
June 2022 by FredeRick Levin
Knowledgeable Sales People
-
June 2022 by Eleonore Schad
Awesome customer service!!! Highly recommended!!!
-
September 2021 by Erica Marie
If you want good quality, affordable, outstanding customer service, and timeliness, you're looking in the right spot. Our experience at McGarry's has been fantastic. We plan on making them our life-long jeweler!
-
June 2021 by Tabitha Schafer
My one and only family Jeweler! Seriously, WHOLE family!! Thank you for helping me get ready for my shoulder surgery and getting rings ? off! Can not wait for you to fix them and make them even better than ever!! Thank you xo
-
June 2021 by Peter Branco
I have been going to McGarry"s from 13/13 years old i met 2 generations and know about the 1st. Great family and when you meet them you are family too. Ask for Tracy all of her friends will help you. Peter
