Gift Shops in Cape May, NJ

14 locations found near Cape May

“The staff in this location are excellent. So professional and courteous. This is a fairly large store with lots of inventory. Lots of beachy items...jewelry..home goods...and a nice children's section. Parking is really an issue even off season. But it's a lovely town and worth the trouble.”

4.9 Superb87 Reviews

“Little gem of a shop in Cape May. So many cute little gifts, very nice selection of jewelry. Many, many gifts for cat lovers! We plan on visiting this shop every year we return to the shore. Highly recommend!”

4.9 Superb52 Reviews

“5 stars all around! Do yourself a favor and book a pottery class with Cat! If you’re like me, who has trying out a pottery class to get it off your bucket list, The Madd Potter’s Studio is the place to go!

Cat’s calming presence, coupled with her words of encouragement results in an enriching experience leaving you wanting to book even more classes. If you’re not local (like me) your masterpieces will be dried, glazed and even personalized with your signature of choice on the bottom.

If you’re in the Wildwood or Cape May area, make your “Ghost” Demi Moore dreams come true!”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“Bought a nice beach ball umbrella with the wooden pole. Trying it out today at Ocean City. Everyone else is taking down their flimsy umbrella and ours is barely moving. The owner gave us good advice on choosing an umbrella. Well worth the cost.”

4.9 Superb22 Reviews

“Like so many others, in Cape May, and when walking the beautiful Washington Mall, I always stop in this store. I usually get something for a friend or two .....but I always purchase several garden flags. I change my flags frequently and this store has the best variety and prices.
I wish I could view the flags and order them online. If, indeed, there is a way, this senior citizen would appreciate the know how,”

4.9 Superb35 Reviews

“Cool little store in mini mall. Music/band themed merchandise. Lots of cool shirts from a bunch of bands. Pricey, but everything is in the mini mall area. Bunch of dead stuff for the dead heads.”

4.9 Superb12 Reviews

“I was so happy to visit this store yesterday. Every time my family and I visit Cape May, my husband knows I HAVE to go there ?. I love all their selections and the calm vibe that you feel as soon as you enter the store. I bought lots of incense (they have the most amazing incense selections ever!!!!), and the staff was very helpful and informative. I give one million stars to this store!✨✨✨”

4.7 Superb73 Reviews

“Wow!! Talk about a pickle paradise!! I’ve been searching for pickled vegetables (other than cucumbers) asparagus being one of my favorites! Cape May Pickle has 8 different varieties of asparagus alone! I love the passion behind their brand you can feel it as soon as you enter! I love that they support all small businesses and it gives you a chance to try more than just one brand, and things from other regions of the US that you might not have tried otherwise. They mentioned 40 plus small businesses! I also love the novelty items like the shirts, mugs, and quirky items! This store is a 10/10! ??????”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“Shop Local is the best! So many unique and beautiful items to choose from! Whether you're looking for something to treat yourself or a gift for that special some, this place has it all!”

5 Superb4 Reviews

“Was on my yearly trip to Capemay and I visit this store every year..such beautiful items..I bought a beautiful seashell outlined with diamonds and a beautiful grey blanket..my neice loved it..thank you for your beautiful things and being so nice❤️”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“This is our favorite place to stop for Christmas ornaments. They have such a variety of specialized ornaments and decorations. Such a cool shop to just walk through even if you’re not planning on purchasing anything.”

4.3 Superb82 Reviews

“An interesting shop with many handcrafted items. Nice selections...great for gift giving. I have purchased really nice holiday ornaments in the past. Owner? Always makes you feel welcome.”

4.2 Good59 Reviews

“PROS: great shop for joke merchandise. It also has gags, games, and the prices are good. Staff is friendly as wellCONS: the place is very cramped and it's uncomfortable if there's a lot of people in thereOVERALL: a very good place to go to if you're in the area if you want a good laugh at some of the things”

3.1 Average22 Reviews