Settler's Mill Adventure Golf is a well-loved mini golf spot on LBI, offering two 18-hole courses: the "caves" course and the "waterfall" course. Located near popular attractions like Fantasy Island and the Thundering Surf Water Park, it has been a part of the island's history for many years. The courses provide a fun challenge with slopes and curves, appealing to both casual players and those learning to read the green. The waterfalls are especially popular on hot days, providing a refreshing and conveniently placed feature, while streams add to the scenic atmosphere—just remember to bring a straw for your water. The courses are kept clean and the atmosphere is friendly, with associates always smiling and ready to help. Although it can get busy, especially during peak times, the staff manages traffic well by offering two different courses, allowing players to choose and switch easily. Visitors enjoy the variety and the chance to challenge themselves, and many appreciate the opportunity to brag about their game afterward. After playing, guests often grab an Italian ice or ice cream nearby to complete their fun-filled day. Overall, Settler's Mill provides a fun, family-friendly experience with a good atmosphere and plenty of options for all ages.
Visited July 5th. Extremely busy but still a lot of fun. A little pricy, but I guess that seems to be the norm for mini golf these days. Very clean, great atmosphere. Two different courses to choose from. Friendly associates offering a smile. Overall a good time for my daughter and I.
July 2025
Nice place. It’s actually two courses in one. Takes a decent amount of time to finish.
June 2025
The theming was amazing and the two courses they had both had fun elements. I recommend going here.
