Thrift Stores near Bayville, NJ

12 locations found near Bayville
View Map

“pricing is good! everything is neat and organized by color and size. the young lady behind the register was very personable and great! definitely will come back”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“I really like this Goodwill . Friendly folx who work there. Have found cool stuff here. 2x complaints : Records are overpriced($2.50) for there condition & price stickers are hard to remove without damaging item.”

3.2 Average89 Reviews

“I love a good thrift store! Hunting for treasures is not only an amazing way to keep items out of growing landfills, but also support worthy community organizations. B&D has become a favorite stop while visiting the Jersey shore. Deena and her lovely volunteers run a beautiful, well organized shop full of the most lovely items I've stumbled across in NJ. If you have time to stop in, it will be worth your time. Prices can't be beat, and you are sure to bring home some very unique gems. 10/10 ⭐️”

4.9 Superb43 Reviews

“My experience has been amazing! I found my best friend, Cooper, at the rescue. The staff was friendly and you can really see that they give each fur baby they have the best attention and love. I can't thank them enough for matching me with my little guy. He is the sweetest dog, and I look forward to loving him for the rest of his life! Thank you, SAVE, for doing what you do, and for bringing my buddy and I together!”

4.5 Superb17 Reviews

“Saint Stephen's is absolutely amazing! I originally went for a baptism but found much more! It was one of the best Churches I have been too! They were genuinely all there for the same reason and that reason is faith. I had lost faith a long time ago and the service I attended this past Sunday brought me back to where I was before it left. I highly recommend Saint Stephen's and I will be returning this Ash Wednesday and hopefully any Sunday when I don't have work. It will be my first Ash Wednesday since I shyed away from religion.Laura MonjoyThe Mysterious Wave LLC, managing member”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews

“My first time there and I am totally in love with this store! It's amazing. The clotges are in size order. The brick a brack is clean. The shoes selection is great. Sheets, blankets, dishes, glasses, records, books. U name it. Can't wait ti go again. Diane and Mary Anne are so helpful too.”

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

“The thrift store is wonderful! Please go to buy clothes here $4-$7 a piece. All the money goes to an excellent cause. They really help as much as possible but are so overwhelmed by the homelessness and people in need. The most caring and hard-working staff.”

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

“This is a great store! Huge! You have to look in all the rooms for what they have. What customers have to remember is, the variety of what is sold is person to what is donated to them they can’t sell what isn’t donated. I walk around in there occasionally and come out with great stuff. Always worth a look.!”

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

“My boyfriend and I found many great things here. Though they don't have the biggest selection of movies compared to other thrift shops. They are priced better than the others.”

3.8 Good18 Reviews

“Just went in with my fiancé and was greeted as soon as we walked in and we were asked if we needed any help! Items were beautiful and well priced, well placed in different sections between entertainment, glassware to even an entire Christmas section!! Bought beautiful vintage pottery and wood pieces Goodwood name brand and found a cameo locket and heart locket!Don’t forget to check their jewelry section in front of the counter and there’s a section behind the counter as well (we didn’t get to check it out, but that gives me another reason to go again along with the owner being absolutely amazing to us)!!!”

3.8 Good40 Reviews

“The therapists there are so good at what they do. They take insurance in and out of network. They care entirely for their clients and even have transportation for you if you don’t drive”

3 Average4 Reviews

“This is such a great Goodwil. Yeah, it's a hot mess and there's stuff everywhere, but the staff is trying and they're always friendly and helpful. I've noticed a lot of the same people working over the years so it must be well managed. They have good prices, and a good selection. Very large digital media section, a lot of shoes and clothing, and usually pretty interesting stuff. They move inventory out pretty fast so there's always new stuff to rummage through. I've found great books and furniture here. Very happy with this particular Goodwill.”

2.8 Average32 Reviews