Toy Stores near Barrington, NJ

30 locations found near Barrington
View Map

“Local place I drove by many of times, decided to pop in to have a look. Really fun place that looks tiny on the outside until you walk in, huge room stacked to the ceiling with nostalgic toys, comics, VHS, DVDs, trading cards. Staff is friendly and easy to chat with. I decided to pick up a tin of pokemon cards, the label on the product was not the price they charge, was a bit surprised but after chatting with the nice gentleman behind the desk, there is no way they could go through every single product in the store and remove/re-label everything, there is just too much stuff! So do not expect to get everything at the whatever old sticker price is on the item a lot but it doesn't hurt to try and haggle”

3.9 Good121 Reviews

“This is the loveliest children's store we could have imagined. We travel frequently and are always in search of a toy store; Tildie's is our summer favorite, tucked away between shops it is a hidden gem. The selection of toys, stuffed animals and so much more was wonderfully curated and the staff couldn't have been more attentive. Thank you for saving us from Amazon: it was a memorable experience.”

4.9 Superb63 Reviews

“Love this place for the comics and the ppl. They are very community oriented and where nice enough to help the children’s tumor foundation raise awareness for the Cupids Undie Run ?? ?”

4.7 Superb103 Reviews

“This has to be one of the best shops to get your collectibles or the best one in general. From the moment that you walk in, you're greeted, you get to meet like-minded people and see just about anything & everything you could want. I've been shopping here for some time now and would highly recommend it. Also The Todd is the best.”

4.7 Superb87 Reviews

“I usually have to venture into philly for comics since everything is closed on Sundays around here for some reason but honestly I'm glad they are cause i wouldn't have found this Gem location as fast. Both trips I've had here the associates have been awesome, kind and well-knowledged. Definitely a cool place with an a great assortment of comics. Even found the Kang issue I've been looking for my collection!”

4.7 Superb68 Reviews

“An amazing shopping experience. The staff was highly knowledgeable and kind. This location had all the sets I needed though being on backorder online.  I received a lot of tips and tricks for building sets. They also went above and beyond and provided me with event information. It is also great to bring your kids to get their lego passports and start their minifigure building and trading. Can't wait to head back for the new releases in June.”

4.6 Superb89 Reviews

“Found some goodies there. Found a Haslab Galactus unopened. The shop is so unassuming from the quaint surroundings of Merchantville; but, when you walk in... whoa!!! I had to use triage for figuring out what I wanted to buy. I will definitely be returning.”

4.6 Superb56 Reviews

“Excellent service from the young woman at the store this morning. She knew the games very well and made very helpful suggestions. Very excited to play with my grandkids!”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews

“Really awesome spot to pick up gifts! I stopped by because of the cute Gritty plush in the window but there's so much more than that. Housewares, candles, jewelry, toiletries, and kids stuff... I like their selection of BAGGU and Blue Q. Staff are helpful and can do gift bags. Items are affordable too. My boyfriend's mom loved what we picked for her!”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“This is my go-to place for getting my books. You have that real comic book store feel and experience when you enter. The owners are very helpful and knowledgeable in the comic book department and can direct you to what you are looking for. They will give you their honest opinion on any story.”

4.7 Superb32 Reviews

“This place is amazing! Video games, board games, action figures, card games, skateboard stuff, and yo yos for professionals. It's eclectic and weird and fun. The staff are friendly. It's definitely worth a look!”

4.6 Superb42 Reviews

“Time Lapse in Collingswood, NJ couldn’t have been more accurately named! This gem takes you back in time to revisit toys, games, decor and other nostalgia from your childhood. A must visit!”

4.8 Superb20 Reviews

“I absolutely LOVE The Happy Hippo. It's such a wonderful place to bring children to pick out toys. It's been a fixture in town for decades and always brings a smile to my face when I see their sign. It's such a joy bringing my kids in to share the same happiness I had as a kid. The charm of a local business brings warmth to the community that the commercial retailers can never provide. Please show them love by making them your "Go-To Spot" for your little one's Birthdays and Holidays.Thank you Happy Hippo!”

4.5 Superb46 Reviews

“This is a great store. Everyone is do helpful. If they don't have what your looking for they do everything they can to find it for you or make recommendations for something just like it. The store is very clean also.”

4.6 Superb30 Reviews

“Cute tiny shop. Tons of adorable stationary and children’s gifts to choose from along with clothing and what appeared to be tailoring services towards the back.”

4.5 Superb41 Reviews

“I'm 18 today and i went to heal my inner child. The staff was so sweet and understanding and I really enjoyed the experience! the prices are pretty understandable too, definitely reccomend!!”

4.4 Superb67 Reviews

“Store was well laid out, selection is decent. Its ollies so dont expect a 10 outta 10 experience, but if you need something like a rug or a heater, and do it on the cheap? Great place to look”

4.3 Superb159 Reviews

“This is just a jewel of a shop! The inventory is so thoughtfully curated for style and durability. The quality of their merchandise is top notch. Definitely worth a visit!”

4.9 Superb10 Reviews

“I went in a bit before the holidays for a present for my baby nephew, the staff was imminently helpful in selecting some toys that were both appropriate for their age and engaging (they were also quite nice as well). I recommend coming here if you have a general idea of what you want to get a younger child and then the staff is equipped to help guide you to something more specific.”

4.7 Superb10 Reviews

“I bought a car charger and it was wrong fit went back to buy another and staff let me do an exchange. I didn't realize I could do that because i opened the package and it was "used"”

4.4 Superb20 Reviews

“Mr. E is great! I've been to lots of game stores over the years, all around the country. I count Mr. E's as one to go to. His pricing is good, his selection is better than good, and his customer service is amazing. I'll be coming here many more times. Come to Mr. E's and buy a game or two!”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“Awesome old school toy store that is packed with any toy you could possibly think of from floor to ceiling. They have some really unique options. Prices are high, but that’s to be expected in a mom and pop. We got our son a fun cow hopper. The gentlemen working and presumably the owners were really nice and personable.”

4.4 Superb15 Reviews

“Mo was immensely helpful when I needed a particular game after searching several different stores for it. This store is also very well kept. Everything is clean, organized, and very welcoming.”

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

“A pretty nice place to go dollar diving. The dollar bins were very numerous, and had a decent selection of both current and older books. I was pleasantly surprised with the selection. Left with 25+ books. Will likely return!”

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

“I recently bought a new Digitrax DCC system from the Yankee Dabbler. The service was great! Bob helped me put my order in over the phone. I live in Kansas and have to drive over 100 miles to find a good Hobbie shop. Nobody beats the prices on DCC systems. They had excellent shipping too. I paid on a Friday and it was here early Tuesday morning. I will be a life long customer. I hope they see this review. Thanks Russell J. Kansas”

4.2 Good33 Reviews

“Mothership you gallery is so fun and creative! Aaron is super friendly and welcomed us into his store to look around and invited us to the art shows. We are super excited to attend his next event.This is such a unique place. I have never seen a store carry custom toys buy artist before.Absolutely love the wide ranges of styles in all the designs. My son absolutely loves anything and all things zombies and creepy toys. I’m excited to bring him in and have him pick something out to take home.”

4.3 Superb14 Reviews

“Alexis was a great help! My husband was on the hunt for a gift because the site wasn’t allowing the item to be ordered and didn’t show which location had it. She got it ordered to be shipped to the house which is great because we don’t live nearby. We always have a great experience at this store and this is just one example of why we prefer to go out of the way to shop here. Thank you Alexis!”

4.1 Good54 Reviews

“I placed an order on November 28 and received timely email correspondence for confirmation of the order and when it was shipped. The items were shipped to Ontario, Canada and arrived on December 13. Shipping was quoted as 14-30 days so it was well under that estimate. I received exactly what I ordered in great condition. I felt a bit nervous making this purchase but the good reviews seemed consistent so I took the risk! I'm so happy I did. I was looking for two hard to find items and I am so please to have them now!! Thank you from Ontario BB Toy Store!!”

4.1 Good50 Reviews