-
August 2024 by Sherry Smith
Ordered a large half supreme and the other half Canadian bacon, green pepper and onions. The crust was not done and had so much cheese on the pizza, I've never seen so much cheese on a pizza before. It did not have sausage, pepperoni, black olives or mushrooms on the half of the Supreme. It is a 10 mile round trip to town so did not take it back but Such a disappointment!
-
August 2024 by McKale Burke
Every time I order pizza here it's messed up last night I ordered LG pepperoni with extra sauce and garlic flavor crust, it barely had any sauce at all and just regular flavor crust. I looked at the receipt it was printed in really big font extra sauce and garlic flavor crust how can it get messed up that bad? Rockport is always on point with their pizza every time I don't recommend Tarkio Casey's for pizza..
-
August 2023 by Timothy Cherry
I ordered 2 small pizzas, they were so salty I couldn't eat but one piece. They gave me 2 free large pizzas, the "real mozzarella cheese" was horrible. I ordered light cheese but I couldn't chew it. It just balled up and I had to spit it out. They need an option of very light cheese! I'm questioning whether it it real cheese. I'm done with Casey's. I wish someone in my area would bring back Hunts Bros Pizza. Now that's a great pizza and a lot more reasonable!
-
October 2022 by David Armstrong
The saddest pizza I ever saw, maybe half the pizza has toppings. They really skimp you these days.
-
August 2022 by Rena Watson
Wouldn’t even give a star at this point. Ordered two pizzas an couple orders of breadsticks online said 20 mins, alright no big deal plenty get here about 25 mins after ordering the pizzas an they say it’ll be another 20 mins bc they got a big order in, so I inform them online it says 20 mins you need to change it. So we wait 20 more mins at this point Kids are hungry, alright we go back an they tell us he’s just now starting our order and it’ll be ANOTHER 15 mins not to mention as we walked in the pizza guy was at the warmers talking bout how he just takes stuff home. This is absolutely ridiculous an I’ve NEVER been so disappointed in a Casey’s store before.
-
August 2022 by Beth Rogers
Love the new Bbq brisket pizza but not enough toppings, especially meat.
-
November 2021 by bobbie irvin
Holy smokes , I’ve heard rumors about the pizza but I was always reluctant (I mean, come on, how good can it be). Ordered the combination and wow, I was blown away!! The ingredients were fresh , crust was perfect, and it was served piping hot, great job guys!! I’ll be back!!
-
September 2021 by Lily Grace
Do NOT buy pizza from this store.
-
April 2021 by Betty Eyman
Staff is ALWAYS friendly when I go there
-
December 2020 by Michael Magaw
It's beautiful love this place.. Country Store from heaven
-
November 2020 by Matthew K
Warmer kept stocked well in mornings.
-
October 2020 by Melanie L
Staff was grumpy and very crabby hard to work with....gas is cheap but pizza staff is awful...easier to get pizza in rock port
-
October 2020 by Amber Herbst
Love Casey's, love their pizza and subs best all in one stop gas station in my opinion
-
October 2020 by Alisha Sachs
Best customer service
-
February 2020 by Gail S.
they always do the best to meet my special diet needs im ketosnd the girld make me lettave wraps and crustless pizzas
