-
October 2024 by red bird
Mean staff
-
October 2024 by Maddy S
My favorite antique store in Stillwater as an avid animal lover. Full of figurines and beanie babies galore for great prices.
-
September 2024 by julia martin
Interesting shop, very large two story, lots to browse. DOWNSIDE: Either bring protection crystals or go in knowing something is there and it is not friendly. My partner and I were in maybe 2 minutes before we both had to leave because of the feeling. I was NOT okay. They seem to have some kind of rock/Crystal arrangement on 2nd floor but it's either keeping the entity there or making it worse don't know.
-
August 2024 by Amanda Gomand
Two story shop with great collections and staff. So much to see, it’s one of my favorite places to stop in Stillwater!
-
July 2024 by Art BanDit
Set the Scene. Its a rainy soaked day in late April. I was in town for 48 hours. Once day spent organizing a house in frog town. I noticed I hadn't gotten my Antique fix in, and I had exactly 5 hours before my fight took off. What more of a healing way to spead a rainy daym then at Estelle vintage. Yeah, its the polar opposite way from the airport, but its the RIGHT DIRECTION to making your house happy. This set up in on the first floor of American gothic antique on main street, and in the back right(right ish) side of the store. Not only did I spend a boat load of time in this boothm but got lost in the attick (per usual) 3rd floor in the glassware. God you guys, its the weekend. Antiqueing is a right of passage. God enjoy the rain with some iced coffee and in this booth. Prices are awesome,the although the R&J soundtrack made me feel old as dirt, the rest made me smile so damn hard. (Pissed that one dress I came in for wan't there, but whatever) Still love this booth!
-
May 2024 by Awn
This place is a absolute must see. Take two hours out of your life to enjoy this experience. Wow. Just go there and you'll understand. The name threw me off but the antiques are incredible everything from lunch pales to comics old board games to beanie babies . Must see . Wonderful people as well
-
February 2024 by Joe Rice
This is a great antique store with two levels packed full of unique finds. Prices are good and customer service is even better. Top three best antique stores I've been to!
-
January 2024 by SR
These people are rude! Don't even bother going in the door!
-
January 2024 by Peggy Guiang
Terrible customer service. Cantankerous man running the business today..Never experienced such rudeness.
-
January 2024 by Natalie W.
Ive been coming here for years and have always had amazing experience. yes there is a lot of stuff but i enjoy diving for my treasure. i also don't think it is fair to judge a building if there is not air conditioning since it's in an older part of Stillwater.
-
December 2023 by Gretchen Gosnell
Lots of goodies! Helpful staff.
-
November 2023 by Tara Harvey
Negative reviews aside, we came here and had a pleasant experience. I don't know if it was the owner or manager who checked us out, but he was nice to talk to. We ended up leaving with several goodies.
-
November 2023 by Pam Myhra
The American Gothic Antiques Store is a must visit for my daughter and me whenever we visit Stillwater! It is located right in the center of the charming town of Stillwater at 236 Main Street South. They are packed with very reasonably priced merchandise. I’ve purchased many items from them over the years including hand school bells and dishes. My daughter has purchased a number of pieces of framed artwork. Be sure to also look upstairs.
-
November 2023 by Nancy Lyn Harley
Love this place!
-
November 2023 by Sydney Arnold
This place is run by the most crotchety old man I've ever encountered, it was almost comical, once the anger retreated. It wouldn't be a big deal if he had simply asked for us to mask up, but instead he ran us out and yelled for not going fast enough (walking with two toddlers)
