-
November 2023 by Cody Leonard
They've done a really good job with this place. The building is nicely built. Many good offerings including sandwiches, ice cream and many baked goods. It also has some gifts for purchase.It won't seem like a tourist trap, but it kind of is. Or offers itself up as that along with a practical, reasonably priced eatery.My understanding is they'll be making their own ice cream eventually and I look forward to trying that sometime.
-
November 2023 by art pirrotta
They make the best sandwiches on fresh homemade bread they are large and extremely low priced. They now make a hamburger that's out of this world. I promise it will be the best hamburger you ever had. A must to
-
November 2023 by John Nagel
The reason for my relatively poor review is that it seems everytime I am here there is an outrageous line that moves very slowly because they accept cash or check only. That is fine.. but if you’re going to do that please have both registers open. It is very poor service to see a line stretching almost the whole length of the store and not open a second register.
-
November 2023 by N Mickhail
Great sandwich made to order fresh at their
-
October 2023 by Dawn F
This place right here , is the Best little Gem I’ve ever found !!!This place has the best Amish apple pies , cinnamon rolls, pastries, homemade milk and yogurts, and deli meat to take home. They also make sandwiches and burgers to go. They also have ice cream in cone or bowl. You definitely need to stop by if you’re ever in the area, you won’t be disappointed. Only take cash or check. Also the ladies that work here are so friendly, Great customer service!!!
-
October 2023 by Verified Factfighter
The best quality foods and milks, I love coming here. You can see a lot of horse and buggies around here and I really enjoy it.My husband and I stop in when we are in Mio and hungry because there's not many restaurants around. The ladies that work in the shop are very friendly, with a good service ethic. There are tables outside amid beautiful flowers and pumpkins where you can enjoy a tasty sandwich and a bottle of fresh milk. They have ice cream too but I have not tried it yet.
-
October 2023 by Raquel Newby
We love their Raspberry Lemonade! We don’t live near their store, but a place near us sells some of their products and they’re good. We go through a jug of their lemonade per week. When we did finally check out their store, everything looked delicious and seems to be quality made. My husband tried a turnover sort of thing and it was very well filled, which isn’t something you see normally.
-
October 2023 by Debbie Gilbert
Awesome ice cream , good prices on lunch meat and cheese. Sandwiches made to order. Cash or check only. Amish owned so no credit cards used
-
August 2023 by Brad Green
Great place with some local goods. We bought 3 pies still warm from the oven. Unfortunately I dont think these are really Amish pies. Very mediocre fillings and taste. We also got ice cream cones that a super tasty and very reasonably priced. We will return, just not for the pies.
-
July 2023 by Brandon Keylor
Great place to shop for fresh homemade goods. They also sell delicious breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches for the most affordable price in a 30 mile or more radius of Mio Michigan. The business is wheelchair accessible. They do take cash or check but I don't believe they take credit cards. I will and do suggest that anyone and everyone stop by The Farmers Creamery. I bet you won't leave empty handed.
-
July 2023 by Jim Ek
Amish store but upscale. Prices are higher than bulk food store. Selection is limited, but quality is up there. Ice cream is good but selection is not as good as Gaylord or Lewiston.
-
June 2023 by Jeremy Hogan
Real Amish people. Very authentic. Best milk ever as well as sandwiches, baked goods, and ice cream. The pickles are a must buy.
-
May 2023 by Krystal Daniels
We always go for a fresh homemade deli sandwich and homemade ice cream. The baked goods are very delicious. Also the deli meat and cheese they have stocked is of very good quality. They have plans to bring in grilled burgers. I've had it in the past and it's the best burger in town.
-
May 2023 by charlesnichols5
Great tasting milk! Plus my wife loves the glad bottles!
-
March 2023 by Harvey Wells
Everyone is awesome here. Super friendly. Run by Amish ladies. It's perfect. Fresh jams and jellies. Fresh milk and chocolate milk. Fresh buttermilk etc. Don't forget that they only take cash and there is a 2 dollar deposit on the bottles. So make sure to bring them back with you next trip.
