Car Rental near Tisbury, MA

14 locations found near Tisbury
View Map

“Our US Census team arrived on Martha's Vineyard and needed to complete census surveys at homes all over the island in just a couple weeks. When we looked at the alternatives, we found A-A Island Auto Rental to be the best and most helpful. Chris & Bryan in Oak Bluffs set us up with Kia Rio's, which were perfect for the small roads, many unpaved, on Martha's Vineyard. The rental process was quick, efficient and courteous. Best of all, they were flexible with our unpredictable schedules. I would highly recommend them! Thanks guys, and we'll see you again in 2030 (but probably sooner too)!”

3.7 Good29 Reviews

“We had a great experience renting from them. Ask for Don the owner. He is incredible. I’m blown away by the negative comments here as our experience was 5 stars or beyond. First timer on the Vineyard & Don was v helpful.”

4.5 Superb72 Reviews

“My wife and I did a walk-in 1 day rental. The staff was incredibly nice and friendly. Cars in Martha's Vineyard are expensive, but this location was the least expensive. Cost aside, the young lady Alex who helped us out was cheerful, kind and very helpful. She helped improved an already great vacation day.The fact that Alex and her colleagues are nice to tourists knowing they will likely never see the same people again says a lot about them as individuals and the office as a whole.”

4.3 Superb39 Reviews

“I only use enterprise now. They are so friendly and helpful. And if you live on the vineyard they come pick you up at the ferry! No cancellation fees either. And they list the exact price unlike many places where the price doubles when they add all their “fees”. I highly recommend enterprise.”

4.1 Good81 Reviews

“This car rental center is easy to miss - indeed, we walked right past it at first - because it's a garage tucked behind a small building with signage for the Wolf's Den pizzeria and a realtor's office. Fortunately, we weren't terribly late for our rental pickup, as the office isn't necessarily staffed all day long, with a friendly young woman calling me to reconfirm my status and waiting for us to arrive. Indeed, it's a small franchise operation, but service was still efficient and personal even though some of the personal details I'd filled out on the Budget website didn't make it through to their computers and/or billing systems. We ended up getting a RAV4 that was in brand-new, tip-top shape and enabled us to make the most of a tightly planned day spent exploring every corner of the island - which made the pricey rental rate worth paying. Mission accomplished!”

4.3 Superb21 Reviews

“Excellent service and we were able to book ahead of time on the way over on the ferry. They were very accommodating and very helpful with recommendations and must see places. Definitely recommend to anyone traveling to the island”

3.7 Good37 Reviews

“Ron provided really incredible customer support - we were trying to figure out options on MV for the Beach Road Weekend and he was a tremendous help. Very personable and a great asset to Hertz on MV! 10/10”

5 Superb2 Reviews

“Jen was extremely helpful not only with the reservation but providing top notch customer service. Will definitely look to rent from Hertz at mvy airport on future trips primarily for aassistance provided by Jen! - Greg E”

5 Superb1 Reviews

“Very efficient operation at this location at the Martha's Vineyard ferry lot. Sadly, they have limited rental hours (but allow after hours drop offs). Big tip: you can drive an Avis car here, drop off and ride the ferry without one way charges. On the way back grab another car here (also wo one way fees).”

2.8 Average25 Reviews

“I've always had a smooth experience here. Returning cars after hours is no problem. They've upgraded me to a sports car when they didn't have the midsize available. They have clean restrooms on site. It's not a far walk to downtown. Only downside is the off-season hours, when they close at 3 pm.”

2.1 Poor29 Reviews

“David Dragas is who I worked with and he went above and beyond to help us when I arrived and when I left. Excellent customer service and always looking at delighting the customer, this is where I will get my next car rental from. I strongly recommend Avis.”

0 Na0 Reviews