-
August 2024 by Rae M
Horrible fudge. Horrible employees. Fudge is honestly disgusting. I would not recommend at all.
-
October 2023 by Yolanda F
Wonderful Carmel popcorn. Chocolate pecan fudge was good very sweet. Worker was unattentive and on the phone.
-
August 2023 by anna diaz
Who make you buy not one not 2 but 3 slices$29 .. or $25 for 2 crazy ? who wants that much
-
July 2023 by Lisa B.
So disappointed with the fudge yesterday! Very, very grainy- tasted like a homemade batch that flops. I'd purchased three slices to take home, so we dipped into another flavor, hoping it was just one off-batch. No luck, all three slices were the same. We've tried the Mackinac Island, MI version and it was so good so I'm guessing whoever was doing the cooking yesterday just missed the mark. Very disappointed.
-
March 2023 by Heather Boswick
Classic spot for yummy treats while on the Beautiful Martha’s Vineyard.
-
November 2022 by Tom Turnus
Pretty bad fudge
-
September 2022 by Melinda Apollonio
Fudge ok customer service the mist unfriendley smiles go a long way and TIP JAR would be full we the customers deserve ro be appreciated since we chose your establishment to spend our money its not a lot to ask!!!
-
August 2022 by Kevin C (kcut10)
Amazing fudge! Some of the best fudge I have every had. Good deal of you buy 3, but it is still a pretty penny.
-
December 2021 by Candy Davie
Disappointed. Fudge was not good at all! It was hard and grainy. Employee that helped us literally hates her job and made sure we knew it. Tw stars because the store was clean.
-
December 2021 by Bridanya
I can't think of any better combination in the world than Martha's Vineyard and Murdick's Fudge! It instantly makes me reminisce and wish I was lucky enough to live on the island forever
-
October 2021 by Candice Davis
Disappointed. Fudge was not good at all! It was hard and grainy. Employee that helped us literally hates her job and made sure we knew it. Tw stars because the store was clean.
-
August 2021 by Ana R.
I was reading through a few reviews after purchasing at the shop, and I'm unpleased to say the issue stays the same. They have horrible customer service, I had never felt more unwelcome in a shop before. Totally needs improvement.
-
August 2021 by CHLOE RAFFERTY
We were the only customers in the store but it took an extremely long time and the workers were rude. The fudge is not good and the place was so hot that when we had the fudge given to us it was halfway melted. One worker also said I would get a free slice but they charged me for it. Spend your money elsewhere.
-
August 2021 by Curtis Rowe
Rude workers. Warmer inside the store than out. Fudge was on the brink of melting as soon as it was served to us. Not cooled whatsoever. Fudge itself was nothing special. Pretty poor experience.
-
August 2021 by Jennifer Mara
The real deal for fudge. I’ll be back time and time again. Wish they had mint chip! I get the s’mores. And cranberry.