“This place has the great combination of a convenience store mixed with the cozy comfort food of a mom and pop restaurant. My grandmother used to make shepherd's pie that was my favorite treat, and when I ate their shepherd's pie I swear I had flashbacks to her kitchen. It's one of the best treats for a great price, and a must have for any shepherd's pie lovers! The staff are incredibly friendly, and when I asked if they could prepare more Shepherd's pie I was happy to find they cooked up a new batch and I ordered all of them.Their whoopie pies are also a great treat for anyone with a sweet tooth. I must have eaten at least a dozen in the month or so I've been here on Plum island. All I can say is that Plum Island Provisions has been the absolute highlight of my trip, and I would recommend them for all manner of delicious treats!”
Variety Stores
“This place has the great combination of a convenience store mixed with the cozy comfort food of a mom and pop restaurant. My grandmother used to make shepherd's pie that was my favorite treat, and when I ate their shepherd's pie I swear I had flashbacks to her kitchen. It's one of the best treats for a great price, and a must have for any shepherd's pie lovers! The staff are incredibly friendly, and when I asked if they could prepare more Shepherd's pie I was happy to find they cooked up a new batch and I ordered all of them.Their whoopie pies are also a great treat for anyone with a sweet tooth. I must have eaten at least a dozen in the month or so I've been here on Plum island. All I can say is that Plum Island Provisions has been the absolute highlight of my trip, and I would recommend them for all manner of delicious treats!”