-
December 2023 by Neil Mulligan
100 feet from the beach and open all year. Friendly people great food and the only place I can get beach Plum preserves.
-
November 2023 by Patrick C.
This place has the great combination of a convenience store mixed with the cozy comfort food of a mom and pop restaurant. My grandmother used to make shepherd's pie that was my favorite treat, and when I ate their shepherd's pie I swear I had flashbacks to her kitchen. It's one of the best treats for a great price, and a must have for any shepherd's pie lovers! The staff are incredibly friendly, and when I asked if they could prepare more Shepherd's pie I was happy to find they cooked up a new batch and I ordered all of them.Their whoopie pies are also a great treat for anyone with a sweet tooth. I must have eaten at least a dozen in the month or so I've been here on Plum island. All I can say is that Plum Island Provisions has been the absolute highlight of my trip, and I would recommend them for all manner of delicious treats!
-
November 2023 by Michelle
As a newcomer to the island I could not believe the quality of food coming out of this lovely place! I have had their muffin tops (the corn muffin is ah-mazing), breakfast sandwiches (perfectly grilled egg, cheese, bacon on english), their steak tip dinner with peppers and yummy thin, salty fries, and my family has had their subs both cold and hot, all equally as yummy! The space is clean, the staff is super friendly, and they are open year round daily. I can't recommend Provisions enough (and have a hard time not ordering from them daily!)
-
October 2023 by Holly G.
Went in to grab breakfast sandwiches this morning. Got a sausage egg and cheese and 2 bacon egg and cheese one gluten free. One of the best breakfast sandwiches I've had in a long time. Not sure what they're using for sausage but it's amazing! Service was fabulous and the new owners are amazing!
-
September 2023 by Cheryl Schepici
My first time here with new owners. Not welcoming. Obviously they didn’t know me so a “hey how are you” atleast would of been nice… I asked what kind of bread other than a sub roll did they offer .. well pardon me…wasn’t asking for your first born…the answer was well we have 4.. ok 4 what…4 wraps… ok which kind .. didn’t bring my crystal ball. The women making it just not pleasant .. I just wanted a tuna to take to the beach first time to plum island beach all summer… also only water offered was polar. They need some more variety. No one looked happy.! Tuna tasted good.. Tk God
-
July 2023 by Nik Novak
Place used to have good BLTS, with new owners everything went up in price, but quality went down, this sandwich has 1 tiny slice of bacon… live on plum but will not be going back here
-
July 2023 by Karin L.
We called ahead to order and pick up a cold sub- the sun was great! Fresh cold cuts, phenomenal soft bread, lots of toppings. Hard to beat the pricing our large fed 2 adults. Great spot to check out when you're at or headed to the beach!
-
June 2023 by David Beattie
Very bad experience in service man did not use gloves and manhandled the frozen pizza dough then proceeded to lick his fingers. It’s lots of screaming from the manager everybody wake up kid with a bucket, hat mumbled do you need napkins? Never going again put on some gloves weirdo
-
June 2023 by Jess Eaton
Friendly workers especially Christian and Kim. Great location near the beach. Didn't try the food yet
-
June 2023 by Mindy Ziehler
I got a sub and it was delicious, the place was so clean. Great people working there. Nice to see it being run by people who love Plum Island.
-
June 2023 by john tardif
The last store on the island delicious pizza sandwiches and more
-
May 2023 by Ryan D.
I ordered a roast beef before 8 people and I waited 20 minutes for them to tell me they ran out of roast beef and I got mine last before everybody else.
-
May 2023 by Adam Fuller
5-1-2023. AAA+++!!! The new owners are great and even better, they actually live on Plum Island! Normal, delicious island food like it should be done here!!! Ordered some fried fish and shrimp and it was wonderful! Not oily or greasy at all. I had given up with PIP until now. Keep up the great work folks and thanks again! Adam F.
-
September 2022 by Kassandra Mariner
Had a fantastic lunch. Husband and I shared a cheese steak and a bbq chicken pizza and both were mouth watering. Just felt bad that the employees were working in those stifling hot conditions. You could barely breathe in the store, Nevermind the kitchen. No AC at all
-
August 2022 by Bethany H.
walked in at 10:23 and they said they stopped making breakfast even though the sign says it closes at 10:30. so i go to order lunch and they said they aren't making hot food for at least another hour, so WTF am i supposed to get a cold salad??? THEN i said f*** it i'll go get an ice coffee and there is no ice! so i politely ask them to get more ice and it takes them TWENTY MINUTES even though i'm the only person in the entire store. this place likes to watch the vacationers suffer
