Menemsha Inn & Cottages is a charming and peaceful retreat located in a low-key part of the island, offering spectacular water views and a rustic yet well-maintained atmosphere. The property features a variety of accommodations, including rooms with a simple coastal aesthetic, polished dark wood floors, tiled bathrooms, and private decks that overlook the water. The sprawling grounds are lush with green grass, vibrant flower beds, and a meandering path that passes chickens, cows, bamboo groves, and leads directly to Menemsha Beach, making the setting ideal for exploration and relaxation. Guests enjoy a range of amenities, such as well-equipped kitchens, fitness center, tennis courts, game and reading rooms, ping pong tables, outdoor showers, and outdoor spaces perfect for unwinding. The inn is within walking distance of Menemsha town, which offers a beautiful beach, fish markets, restaurants, and shops. Nearby activities include Lucy Vincent beach, Aquinnah cliffs, and the Chilmark general store, catering to easygoing travelers seeking a tranquil escape. Service experiences vary; many guests note the welcoming staff, especially Virginia, who provides thoughtful gestures like beach passes and personalized attention, although some found staff interactions to be less hospitable. The inn also has a sister property, The Beach Plum, where complimentary breakfast is available. Overall, Menemsha Inn & Cottages is considered a little piece of paradise, perfect for a quick getaway or a relaxing vacation, with hopes expressed by visitors to return again and again before the season ends in October.
We love this place. Rustic, but well cared for. The location is why we come, simply spectacular views and in a low key part of the island. Well equipped kitchens and walk to Menemsha town over boardwalk and dunes.
August 2025
Nice quiet place away from the crowds at the other end of the island. We had a cabin that was well kept.
June 2025
Wonderful place for a get away, incredible service in a quaint, quiet area. Rooms are beautiful, fitness center and tennis courts. Staff go above and beyond to accommodate guests. We stayed in the carriage house accommodations and were very pleased.
