This is a fantastic store for both locals and tourists. Their candy collection is awesome. Their products are a great quality and this is a great old store. I didn't ask, but this place is very old and there doesn't appear to be wheelchair access.
December 2023
A store from last century. A great place to visit with penny candy and a menagerie of supplies and gifts. Fun to walk around, but you always walk out with something without losing your wallet.
December 2023
Neat spot. They have roasting peanuts in an antique case, a micro candy shop, and many unique gift options. I wish I was there early enough to try the donuts. It's worth a stop.
Built as a church in 1852, the building was converted to general store in 1866. Situated at the Heart of Brewster, the store serves locals and tourists alike, providing a "Third Place" for friends to meet on the benches from the morning, with fresh coffee, donuts and pastries, to night with an ice cream cone from The Brewster Scoop next door. Inside is a broad, but unique assortment of merchandise including penny candy, our own design t-shirts and sweat shirts, jams and jellies, greeting cards and kitchen gadgets, linens and many other unusual gifts from the past and present. Our book section includes the recently released A HISTORY OF THE BREWSTER STORE, The Heart of Brewster. And do not forget our broad array of lamp parts and chimneys.
