-
September 2024 by Penelope Molenburg
I noticed a huge improvement in the store.The shelves are stocked. Doughnuts are fresh. Pizza is good and piping hot. Staff is friendly including the new manager Jessica. I think I have a favorite store!!! Keep up the good work!!!
-
January 2024 by Jessica Balvanz
One rude girl, but I haven't seen her and hoping she is gone for good. The rest of the staff is helpful, but lunch only consists of burgers or pizza or chicken sandwich or tenderloin. They used to have more fresh hit variety, like this bbq pull pork sandwhich that was amazing, but Casey's did away with it, unfortunately. Every time i go there on my lunch break, I'm late getting back to work bc the lines are long and not enough staff.
-
December 2023 by Robert Evans
I spent over an hour on hold to cancel an order . I never got to speak with anyone. I truly hope everyone appreciates the pizzas I ordered for breakfast because I will not be there to pick them up.
-
August 2023 by savants08
This is absolutely the worse Casey's in existence. The pizza is never ready on time. The fountain drink machines never have ice. Just now all the machines were without ice, the icee machines not working. It's pathetic. They desperately need new leadership. We drive out of our way to order from other caseys to avoid this location.
-
June 2023 by Jimmy Stevens
I paid for extra toppings and it felt like I got less than the original amount... The cooking lady was overworked with no help, and customers were waiting 30 minutes longer for their food than the app told them.
Parking: Lots of parking available
Wheelchair accessibility: Persons that needed a ramp were having to park further away from the entrance... Doesn't make sense.
-
May 2023 by Strong Joe
I’m not sure why Casey’s allows the app to work for this destination, typically the 25-30 minutes the app says doesn’t give them time to begin making a pizza, let alone cook and box it. 5/6 times over the last year I have ordered pizzas and they haven’t been done on time, they hadn’t started the pizza when I got there, or claimed they didn’t have my order. Employees who make pizzas and the shift manager on duty never attempt to make the delays or miss order correct, then they are some of the most disrespectful people I’ve ever seen in a place of business when there’s an issue. Employees at this place are typically always in over their heads. We love Casey’s pizza, just not this Casey’s. Only use this location in an emergency. To add to this, ice cream machine is always broken down, baked good are always gone, fuel pumps don’t print a receipt.
-
April 2023 by James D.
It is a typical Casey's upgraded/replaced a outlet years ago. The pizzas are good. The service good.
-
February 2023 by Amanda VanderLeest
My taco pizza stink. The chips were stale And it was so tough.
-
October 2022 by Tyler Hoskins
It’s convenient and the staff are mostly friendly. The only gripe I have is that between 6-8am it’s extremely busy. A lot of people are trying to get a quick bite or gas on their way to work. Having both registers open at this time would be extremely helpful.
-
October 2022 by Nathan Teumer
Shouldn't have to wait in line for 20 minutes to get a recipt, shouldn't have to insert chip card 3 times and then try swiping mag stripe everytime but that's how we roll at the Montezuma casey's
-
September 2022 by Nikki Stephenson
Convience and friendly checkers for the most part
-
September 2022 by Boe Tompkins
Guaranteed to mess up your order everytime! Never fails
-
July 2022 by Joshua Atwell
Didn’t get any marinara sauce with my order of breadsticks. Guess that they just assume that people don’t want it when they order breadsticks. What kinda physcopath orders breadsticks but doesn’t get marinara ?♂️ Guess the “A team” was out that day.
-
July 2022 by Mitch Hammes
Gas prices this morning were $4.79 mean while in Oskaloosa it is $4.39 a gallon at Casey's. And in What Cheer, New Sharon and Brooklyn it is $4.50 a gallon. I can't believe you would price gouge your customers like that in this economy.
-
June 2022 by Shi Murphy
I always have trouble trying to get fuel at this location. It always says "Insufficient Funds, try lesser amount" which i know is not correct. So I go across the road to the other convenience store and be done fueling in the amount of time it takes Caseys pump to tell me Insufficient funds! This has happened multiple times so I don't even try to get fuel at Casey's anymore.
