-
March 2024 by Haile Kahl
I absolutely wish I could give this company zero stars. My boss ordered us a large bacon breakfast pizza. He sent one of my coworkers to pick it up. They handed her the wrong order and made her pay for it, after the order had already been paid for online. We came back to get a refund and our actual pizza, the guy in the kitchen handed us our pizza and demanded the other pizza back because the guy it was already there and asking for it. After a pizza has left the store, or any food for that matter, it should NEVER be resold. That’s disgusting. The entire time we’re trying to explain what happened to the cashier the kitchen person was in the back screaming about how horrible we were, well the assistant manager was letting him sit there and yell about us well we were still in the store. Extremely rude customer service. We order pizza from there on the regular and we are severely disappointed and will not be ordering again.
-
March 2024 by Robyn White
Always clean, you always get a greeting when you walk in.
-
February 2024 by Colleen Matson
Pizza over cooked. Hard to chew. Easy to order but did NOT taste good.
-
January 2024 by Jacob Fairchild
Of the two Casey's in town this is the better of the two. Food is always available where as the other store is a hit or miss . I wish the slices were cheaper but it's worth
-
September 2023 by Temperance Bettin
Me and my friends go here almost every day and the workers are more than happy to speak abt our day with us and be very polite!! Over all very clean and amazing slushies!!
-
June 2023 by Glenn H.
Great pizza, who would of thought the best pizza in town came from a gas station. We've tried several different toppings & have never been disappointed.
-
January 2023 by Missy Carlson
Was in and out! Was awesome i found sour apple alcohol not even Walmart sell itParking: I was surprised to see the place not busy
-
October 2022 by Monica Miller
After calling in an order and being told it would be ready at quarter after four I got there had to wait for somebody to even acknowledge I was standing at the counter for almost 10 minutes and once they did they told me they never made the order very frustrating never going back again
-
June 2022 by V Brown
Beautiful nice clean and organized store. The have great staff
-
June 2022 by Ken Moine
Great ? and great sub ?. Good-bye Pizza Hut, good-bye Subway.
-
March 2021 by D L
I ordered online this morning and Curtis was awesome he was making sure my order was right, very attentive and courteous. I was so happy with his service. Ppl like that def make your day better. Thank you!!!
-
February 2021 by Taylor Hall
we ordered pizza from this place today and it was okay. when we were eating we found a hair in the pizza. we called and asked for a new one and they did that. when we got the 2nd one , there was a hair in that one as well. not okay.
-
February 2021 by Mariah Coleman
Leaving a review on a gas station seems odd but I had a nice experience here. I got a sub and the person at the counter named Monique was super friendly, nice, and took great care when putting my sandwich together! Overall the staff here are always very nice and efficient
-
January 2021 by John Hanks
This is the best Casey's pizza in town. Orders are almost always on time and they typically get our online orders correct. If not, be nice to them and they will fix the issue. Good work South Casey's!
-
January 2021 by Shawn Pilcher
Amazing pizzas Subs etc etc. Prices are good. And the store is clean
