6AM - 10PM
1109 3rd Ave, Alton“The employees are wonderful people here. I feel safe and comfortable here. The environment and people are so helpful and caring. Its the best place in Orange City to spend money.”
5AM - 11PM
704 8th St SE, Orange City“Casey's has the best pizza I have ever had! They always use the best ingredients, and the crust is always fluffy and tastes great. When you order, they usually have your pizza ready when you get there. The workers at Casey's are very helpful and nice. Highly recommend Casey's pizza. It's always amazing!”
“Hands down, THE BEST Casey’s pizza I’ve ever had. The cheese hugs your taste buds with a warm, salty embrace. The sauce is perfect - not too much, not too little, with a fire roasted flavor and delightfully herbaceous finish. The crust isn’t like other crusts - it’s warm, fluffy, and flavorful, like the dough was kneaded by my own Italian grandmother’s gnarled arthritic hands. And they are consistent - 100% on point, every time, handed over with a smile and a friendly conversation. The kids that run this store know how to make a pizza!”