Casey's in Spencer, IN, located at 639 W State Hwy 46, is known for its made-from-scratch dough and fresh toppings, offering a delicious pizza experience that families love. The taco pizza is especially praised as a standout dish. Customers appreciate the pleasant service, with some staff members going above and beyond to rectify issues, such as equipment malfunctions leading to missed orders. However, recent management changes have led to some dissatisfaction, including the loss of online ordering and earlier closing times. There have also been complaints about food quality, particularly with pizza that arrived raw. Despite these challenges, the commitment to customer service remains a positive aspect of Casey's. Alongside pizza, the store provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and essential groceries, making it a convenient stop for various needs, including quality fuel for vehicles.
Caseys sold me 3 packs of nasty vape pods and we're kind enough to allow me to return and then replace them, even without the receipt I lost. Thanks again.
July 2024
The pizza is always a family favorite. Loaded with with the correct, fresh, yummy, toppings every time. Service is pleasant. Thank you Spencer, IN CASEY'S.
July 2024
Casey’s had an equipment malfunction and our pizza order was never received. Angela in the kitchen took an aweful situation and turned it into a positive. People like her aren’t appreciated enough. Thanks again for going the extra mile to make it right.
