-
September 2024 by Matthew Salmons
Carmack is such a cool place. Eddie taught me how to navigate the sticks I think the ole’ pallet wants, or is always willing to suggest additions if I am looking for something to add to the golf bag mini humidor. I highly recommend checking this place out !
-
August 2024 by Nick Tucco
Good selection of pipe tobacco. Premium types I can normally only find online.
-
February 2024 by Richard brown
A caveat, I went to Carmack’s to look for empty cigar boxes to make cigar box guitars out of. They had a good selection and the staff was very nice.
-
January 2024 by Mike
Great environment to have a cigar with some friend out of the elements!!!
-
January 2024 by Stephanie
Horrible customer service. They are very rude. I highly recommend going somewhere else.
-
December 2023 by TJ F.
Honestly wish I could give this place 0 stars.. even 0 stars is too many this guy thinks anyone who walks in is an idiot. He doesn’t educate you on cigars he shames you for not knowing anything about them. Don’t go here.. in fact don’t even walk past here he’s in the window giving rude looks.
-
November 2023 by shirley cooley
Very nice. The parking stinks.
-
November 2023 by Jason Breitwieser
Eddie found the right cigar for the occasion. His selection is superb!
-
August 2023 by Luis Gomez
1st and last time in there, the guy is very rude and no hospitality skills at all, fell very unwelcomed while I was there. This is the only place I would not buy from as far as small local businesses goes. Do yourself a favor and dont waste your time here. Habana in Fishers is very nice place with plenty of selection and friendly stuff.
-
August 2023 by Mike Cook
Stopped in for some cigarsFriendly staff. Large selection.Lounge area looked awesome.Will visit here again if I'm in the neighborhood.
-
July 2023 by drew fullhart
Best, most clean, cigar and pipe tobacco shop/lounge I've ever been in. Guy knows his stuff and is super nice to helping beginners.
-
July 2023 by Raymond Erdos
Maybe just having a bad day or just need some lessons in hospitality. I won't be back.
-
June 2023 by Lan Dar
If I could give zero stars I would... If I could give negative stars, I would. The service is is utterly horrible. I gave this place a second chance. I figured people have bad days. Nope! Same rude guy, same horrible attitude. I know a bit about cigars and he treated me like dirt. DO NOT GO HERE. There are a few places around that have decent selection and the staff are much nicer at these places.
-
June 2023 by Dennis Wasonga
Wide variety, with very knowledgeable staff. Has a smoking room in the back and also offers drink and cigar pairings for the aficionados.
-
April 2023 by rob
Would of at least left a 3 star but second rate cigar shop. Owners rude. Not classy at all will definitely take my business elsewhere. Oh and the cigars in the humidor are dry as all hell almost turning to dust in my hands. Ugh
