Toy Stores in Indianapolis, IN

23 locations found near Indianapolis

“My family and I LOVE The Toy Pit! The staff is always so friendly and helpful. Mark & Mike were so kind today and Their energy alone makes this place worth coming to! Toy Pit has so many collectibles and it's always something new available that you'll love to have im sure.”

4.8 Superb220 Reviews

“Came here today to play in the Star Wars Planetary Qualifiers and I am so grateful to have had such amazing hosts. They treated all the players with respect, the owners dressed up in amazing costumes to celebrate the occasion, and they were generous enough to provide food and drinks for the players since we were there for 12 hours.

The location is a good size, hosting over 100 people, and they offer a good selection of products at pretty reasonable prices.
I'm not from the area (Ohio dweller) so I'm sad to say that I can't come out here regularly, but as someone who visits many games stores I can say that the owners of this location truly go above and beyond to make sure their guests are happy. I travel for work and will definitely stop by here again the next time I'm scheduled for Indianapolis.”

4.9 Superb173 Reviews

“Phenomenal experience, here. Tons of short boxes to browse through...and some really good prices on most. Snagged a few wall books, too. Went back 3 times, during my stay in Indy.”

4.8 Superb127 Reviews

“I'm from out of state and went there while visiting a friend. It is very comfortable, very well presented with nice wooden shelving, carpeting and a nice area in the back for gaming. The games were well displayed and the staff were very kind and helpful. Next time I visit, I'll definitely come again.”

4.7 Superb135 Reviews

“This place was awesome. I have seen it many times but never stopped. We mainly came I'm because my son loves pokemon cards. Lots of those but so many toys from my childhood. Very cool place.”

4.8 Superb96 Reviews

“Best buy/sell lego store out there! I love coming here to look around and buy lego from their huge selection of stuff. Everyone is nice and helpful. This place is awesome I cannot wait to come back!”

4.6 Superb145 Reviews

“Living near this place is both a blessing and a curse! A blessing in that I get to easily attend the game nights that they have. A curse in that I spend way too much here! They have everything you need if you are looking for DnD, Warhammer, Infinity, MTG, dice, and so much more! They have a good miniature selection too!

The game nights are fantastic! If you are new, they are welcoming and will take the time to help you understand the game and how to get started. Great place to pick up different types of board games for you and your family.”

4.7 Superb130 Reviews

“Wonderful selection and super friendly employees. Very talkative and fun even with just buying a couple mystery packs. Everything was very clean and well kept. Always love stopping at a Lego store!”

4.6 Superb120 Reviews

“Wonderful kids bookstore. The shelves are pretty full but super organized. The staff is friendly and helpful. Plenty of free parking on the street and behind the building.”

4.9 Superb50 Reviews

“Ordered a couple of Breyer models and they shipped the same day! They arrived the next day as well, it probably helps that I am a state away but I was very impressed with the service and will definitely order my models more regularly from this store!”

4.7 Superb15 Reviews

“Thank you for always being so supportive of The Benton House.We can’t count the number of times and ways you’ve supported us.We love you and all you do, often silently, to support the neighborhood!”

4.4 Superb115 Reviews

“What a wonderful store! The store had wonderful options for all budgets and the store associate was incredibly helpful, helping me find a perfect gift. Thank you!”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“Cool finds & really good deals! Great customer service also! Glad we came across it last year. Dont think we've ever left without finding something for someone lol this pick-up if Father’s Day gift! Thanks Jack for finding it in the back! Always good shopping with you! Love to support local business :)”

4.5 Superb11 Reviews

“Posted on Yelp

Great bargains, great prices, awesome deals. Parents suggested this place for some valued items and they had most items I needed! From some groceries so house decor. This store has it all. Service was great and even though only 1 lane was opened, the cashier individualized the transaction and was very polite!”

4.3 Superb234 Reviews

“Stuff changes every few weeks. Most prices are half of normal. But that's sometimes at least 60% of stock is my guess. I always save when shopping here. Household stuff and some food. Kind of like a small KMart.”

4.3 Superb131 Reviews

“Lots of books for $1 when I visited, but I only found some Disney coloring books worth wanting to purchase. The games were somewhat interesting, with a surprisingly large variety of sub-types for the classic boardgame "Monopoly."”

4.1 Good42 Reviews

“Great store with a variety of kits, materials, pieces and parts for many different hobbies (trains, Gundam, model building, etc). Very clean and staff members were kind and helpful.”

4.2 Good178 Reviews

“They got mostly everything vintage! A huge collection of Funko pops to old vintage TV shows merchandise like Power Ranges, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Star Wars, and much more! They are having a big sale, so please come and check it out!”

4.1 Good97 Reviews

“Took my daughter to get her first ear piercing. Had a awesome experience with Amber and Kristine. They made the process fun, quick and easy for my daughter. They were kind and thoughtful about her comfort. Thank you”

4 Good79 Reviews

“What's nice is you can get single dollar amounts for your Xbox (no other consoles) for gift cards. They will be printed pass codes. I do wish they could do this with all consoles because of taxes are still applied online. Good atmosphere and employees.”

3.8 Good82 Reviews

“Updated review (POSITIVE):
No other children’s resale store has the selection (with this kind of pricing) as this Once Upon.for example, I bought a pair of Nike Flex Runners for my daughter that were $3.50!!! The on sale retail price is still $30!
Over the past month, I have been able to stock up on Fall essentials (including shoes), Halloween costumes, and have even been able to start shopping for Christmas outfits.
Not only have I been able to shop for these things, but there is PLENTY for those who have come before me and those that will come after.
My twins are almost 18 months and we are outside playing EVERYDAY, so as you can imagine, clothes take a beating. But, with this Once Upon, I’m able to buy them things to keep their closest full and their play clothes a plenty.
Another plus is the way that they have remodeled their selling area. It feels like it is more streamlined, less crowded and, honestly, I’ve had nothing but fast experiences the last few trips to sell.
100% recommend this a Once Upon??

***
Previous review:
I love this OUAC! I buy and sell here all the time. They really allow their customers to follow the buy, sell, trade idea by buying from their customers and offering fair prices for what they buy and what they’re selling in-store. The staff is also amazing! They work quickly, while also being kind and showing interest in their customer base.”

4.1 Good186 Reviews

“Destiny was wonderful. She was the only one working and was absolutely working her butt off. Regardless, she still took the time at the stuffing station to make every child have a special experience, while single handedly managing questions, the phone, and the register. Nice job Destiny!”

3.9 Good127 Reviews

“One of the best Once Upon a Child locations in Indy (and surrounding areas)! It is clean with ADA accessible aisles, has kind and helpful staff, a clean and working bathroom, and a good selection of clean and quality items at decent prices! I have been to this location about five or six times over the course of the past ten months and have only had one negative experience here. We all have bad days though, and this location is still so much better and more clean, welcoming, and accessible than other locations. This is definitely the best location for a consistently good experience. I had another wonderful experience here this week and had to post a review. I definitely recommend shopping here for used games, childrens clothes, toys, books, and more, even if it’s not the nearest location to you! It will be worth the drive.”

3.9 Good140 Reviews