Thrift Stores in Indianapolis, IN

30 locations found near Indianapolis

“Stopped in the "furniture" side while trying to find 5he "antique" side. I was impressed and mad that I didn't know about this place when I was looking for new furniture. I will recommend and keep it in mind in the future”

4.8 Superb136 Reviews

“I’m in such a pickle trying to find a gown for a formal dance I’m going to volunteer for this Friday night.. I called the Toggery this Wednesday. The woman who helped me on the phone shopped for me with me on the phone to see what was in stock. With my needed larger size it made it easy for her on the phone call. She knew where to look for any and all pieces to put together an outfit. What unbelievable and helpful service I received! I cannot wait to shop in person there!! I’m sorry I didn’t get her name.”

4.6 Superb105 Reviews

“I've been a few times, and like all thrift stores, some visits have been better (for me) than others. It's a great size - big enough to have a large selection, but it's not overwhelming. Merchandise is clean, well organized, and reasonably priced. The staff is very friendly. Highly recommend.”

4.5 Superb113 Reviews

“Mission 27 takes care to ensure they are selling quality and clean used products which is greatly appreciated. The prices are always great and they have even kept prices low in an economy where that is not common anymore. Evon helped me and my boyfriend buy a sofa the last time we were there and she was helpful and great!”

4.3 Superb78 Reviews

“This is one of the best consignment shops for men's clothing on the Northside of Indy. Top brand names in great condition are the norm. Shopping full price retail anywhere after going to Newman & Company gives me sticker shock, so I keep going back.”

4.3 Superb138 Reviews

“Great place to find kids clothes and toys at a lower cost. The staff is so nice and have helped me many times- both with finding things and selling things. I'm so grateful to be close to a location.”

4.2 Good158 Reviews

“I have driven by this place for years, and was always curious, and today I decided to donate many things, for the Julian Center does not take in-house donations anymore. (86th and Ditch now @ Thrifty Threads), which is also a great cause, but I didn't feel like making the drive. As a South-Side resident, I appreciate the convenience, and the staff was more than happy to accept my donation of clothing. This store is cute, quaint, and clean, and there are many rooms to explore. I will definitely return to this shop and spend a few dollars, literally. Thank you gals and guys for all you do! I think this place is a treasure trove that I will share with friends and family. Keep up the good work, thank you!”

4.8 Superb32 Reviews

“I love this place! My family loves coming here as well as friends. We treat ourselves by coming here when we can! Much like Mission 27, it is organized and has great vintage selections but I’d say thrift threads has better vintage/retro selections and for that reason some items might be pricey. They have fitting rooms and a large selection of women’s clothing And have a fairly small selection of plus size in comparison to the total amount of clothes they have. Prices can be good will cheap to consignment prices. Love that it’s close to a great taco and tamale place, 3in1!”

4.1 Good108 Reviews

“I was just wondering, enjoying a wonderful day and decided to stop at one of my favorite bargain stores. I found a couple of great deals. Staff were busy and friendly. And, I look forward to returning soon. ??”

4.1 Good86 Reviews

“I had questions and it seemed like only 1 person had all the answers and was busy. I ended up leaving without purchasing anything. Overall it was still a nice store and probably one of the cleanest locations. I will go back at another time.”

3.9 Good113 Reviews

“Typical Goodwill thrift store, with inexpensive "pre-owned" clothing and other items for sale. Staff was helpful. As an added bonus for penny pinchers, there is a Dollar Tree and a Save-a-Lot nearby.”

4 Good65 Reviews

“The workers here were amazing,I went in with my step mom to look for some clothes for work and a instrument and I didn't find any so I asked for one and they looked in the back and found me a piano aimed for beginners for 10 bucks!(What a steal),I got up to the counter and I got to enjoy a conversation about music and got everything for way cheaper then what I expected,10/10 shopping trip will definitely return thank you guys for the great service”

3.9 Good87 Reviews

“Great array of new furniture/closeouts and reconditioned appliances. They offer financing. Delivery is a little pricey, but convenient if you don't have a truck!”

3.9 Good65 Reviews

“Scott thank you for being a kind human being. You are an asset to the Salvation Army, you smile and greet people and I even heard you say Hola to a Hispanic family to make her feel welcome. You deserve to be advanced to management because your other colleague lacks people skills- well I should say he discriminates as to who he will use his people skills with. He never greets me when I walk in the store, but then someone else will walk in and he acts as though he is the epitome of kindness. Scott is the only reason why I give 5 stars. As for the dude who seems like he is always PMSing when I come to that store I will find out who is above him and report him. Never assume because a person comes to Salvation and shop that they have to because I don't.”

3.7 Good56 Reviews

“This is a great place to go for furniture! They have all types of different styles of furniture, couches, love, seats, household furniture as well. I also have a large variety of different products and items that are at a very, very good price! I highly recommend coming in and checking this place out. It is one of my favorite go to places! Before you go to the furniture store, stop by here!”

3.6 Good30 Reviews

“All the stuff I got today was 50% off.They actually have a large inventory of men's clothes, more than any thrift store I've seen. I even got 2 brand new pairs of Carpenter jeans for $2.49 each. !!!”

3.6 Good71 Reviews

“Great selection of clothing and the staff was extremely accommodating and nice towards me and my family. Will be coming here over and over again. Thank you for the help today!”

3.6 Good89 Reviews

“nicely organized store with fair prices. goodwills have usually gotten out of hand lately with their pricing but this one was not. employees were all friendly as well. when the lines got long, they called more people up to the register. I would shop there again!”

3.6 Good95 Reviews

“This Goodwill location gave great customer service, it had a good selection of items, the prices were fair, & the staff answered any questions that my wife & I had as well as loaded the U Haul truck we had brought back to pick the furniture items we had bought. I was overall very satisfied with this Goodwill.”

3.6 Good96 Reviews

“Always friendly and clean. Good deals. It's hard to find decent clothes for men, we usually wear our stuff beyond repair.They have super sells on certain dates, but I'm not the one to stand in line. The staff are really friendly.”

3.6 Good106 Reviews

“I would like to thank Clickgoodwill for being honest, I bought book named “ Marinas and small craft harbors” through Amazon, it’s supposed to be used book, and they “mentioned Pages may include limited notes, highlighting, or minor water damage but the text is readable.”Actually, the book which I received almost like a new, it was in perfect condition, I couldn’t find single defect.Really appreciate your honesty. All the best for you.Warm regards from Kuwait”

2.7 Average7 Reviews

“Everyone in their mother's uncle's nephew's great grand-niece was there on a Sunday evening 'round 5pm. The place is huge. A lot of bins with clothes (mostly) but also some furniture and misc garage stuff. There were basically no dishes or kitchenware items. They charge $1.79/lb for stuff, unless an item is over 15 lbs then it might be priced differently.

I couldn't find very good quality clothes, but that may vary day-to-day. People in there move + dig FAST like they're racing to grab the good stuff... honestly just take your time and hope you find something good. I'd prefer to just go to a regular Goodwill.”

3.5 Good100 Reviews

“My friend today in need if a dryer! Doing a little searching here or there on marketplace with little to no success on a dryer mainly over priced as to the reason! She decided maybe check in at goodwill and see if they have one! Blessings come I'm ways you can't imagine or when, reluctantly maybe to many dryers or no space! She managed to buy one at a low price you wouldn't believe! I am so grateful that Goodwill stores exist and how far they go to help someone in need! ??”

3.4 Good96 Reviews

“Wow, this is definitely the best Goodwill I have ever been to! Not kidding. I have been to a "couple" all around Indiana and this one is by far the best for several reasons. 1. This gentleman who works there (Feb 20, 24) was going round to each isle and sorting and straightening items. It was so well organized! I told him too! 2. I got an important phone call from my doctor when I was getting ready to check out, I could do both. I asked the cashier if I could park my cart near the register and run outside to take call. She watched it for me the whole time I was outside! She was very nice and professional. I told her how much I appreciated her help. Thanks PAT!!! 3. The store was very clean and restrooms were very clean. I definitely give it 5 stars!”

3.4 Good95 Reviews

“I purchased an item from this goodwill online from, and it shipped to Delaware. For starters they packaged it up better and safer than Amazon and as a 20 year buyer on eBay nothing comes to mind being so well and safely packaged but can certainly recall countless that arrived damaged due to lack of packaging material and carelessness. Nothing like receiving something you bought arrive broke or just carelessly thrown in box. So that was nice. it works great looks great and whoever I delt with or delt.with me was super helpful, very nice, professional and patient with me”

3.4 Good73 Reviews

“Ashley and lanyiah were awesome and both need a raise.great customer service and smiled even tho I am disabled I enjoyed my shopping as I always so at this location because it is near my home.”

3.4 Good117 Reviews

“These 2 cashier girls, both with red hair, were very sweet and kind, after I forgot my receipt, I went back home to get it, and as soon as I came back, they instantly remembered me, one of their names is Lizzy, I hope they stay for a while”

3.3 Good82 Reviews

“Another Goodwill headquarters over here on the West Mission Street do a great job with helping this able people to get back to work back into the workforce get their social life together and other services that they provide that you might find interesting if you want to apply for a job with the Goodwill of Central Indiana trust me if anything that you can do to help them do it donate clothes cars appliances or something like that then you can get all in good working condition that they can make a profit off of the help benefit of the individuals with disabilities.”

3 Average54 Reviews

“Updated review in 2024: The store has improved in cleanliness and selection! Great deals here, and staff are friendly.

Original review from 2017: The store is kinda dirty, and there are generally some pretty angry people shopping here. It feels depressing. Also, they don't have a very good selection of clothing for men.”

3.2 Average89 Reviews