-
February 2024 by Mickey Perry
I love this place! Always helpful! Very friendly and always ready to make a suggestion on cook or something new to try. It’s my one stop butcher shop!
-
January 2024 by doughinshaw1
Regarding my recent order of 90 New York Strips , I'm disappointed with the presentation of the steaks. They were requested to be 1" thick and the full order was not consistent in cut. They ranged from 1/2" - 1" in thickness. In addition, each steak was individually vacuum sealed and the meat did not appear freshly cut.This is the second year I have placed this large order for my company's lunch. There was a significant change in the overall quality of what I received this year and what I expected from Kincaid's.I have always had a high opinion of Kincaid's but I will have to reevaluate my options for next year.
-
November 2023 by Tina Terry
This was my time buy from here. I brought 4 chicken breast & 2lb of party wings. I made mesquite chicken and my son ate 3 out of the 4 chicken breast. It's the most moist chicken I've ever had. Definitely purchasing my meats from here going forward. Definitely different from what I purchase in the store. This was the change I was looking for. Plus It did not upset my stomach.This chicken was ???!!!
-
October 2023 by wendeljcw
Friendly service, quality meat.
-
August 2023 by Tyler
This place carry’s Nueskes Bacon and it’s the main reason this shop gets a 3 star.What’s taking away from making this a five-star experience is the toxic tipping culture at Kincaid’s. Why am I prompted to tip for buying $20 of pre-packaged bacon?This system guilt trips the client and it makes me just want to go to Moody’s so I’m not being apart of why the guy behind the counter is being underpaid.
-
July 2023 by Beau Parsons
Purchase from them for special guests (top of the line steak and shrimp). Had an issue with steak but they corrected it and made it right immediately.
-
February 2023 by Lainey B
Great butcher. Glad they expanded to a 2nd location. Love their meat selections.
-
January 2023 by Ethan Aberg
Drove 45 minutes for it to be closed early on a Saturday. Was about 10 minutes before closing time but saw two other people walk up to the door and try it while I was here. Bummer.
-
January 2023 by Rob H.
Best meat in the area, but expensive. Service was good, selection is great. Definitely worth a trip.
-
July 2022 by Whitney Klein
I mean when it comes to meat, this is the only place you really want to buy. Fresh Prime cuts, fresh stuffed sausage. Tonight I split a charcoal, and hickory grilled porterhouse with my son. Easily one of the best steaks I’ve ever had in my life. #greatbutchergreatsteak
-
June 2022 by Kristi
Best burgers we've ever had! They melt in your mouth!
-
June 2022 by Stacey B.
First time customer and definitely NOT my last visit. I came for their Italian sausages for a Father's Day grill with my Dad and the quality/taste was amazing. Also, customer service was awesome as one of the guys pointed me to their freezer section to save some $ if I was open to frozen product. He said they freeze their meats as soon as the product just begins to verge on not being fresh. In my opinion, this makes good business sense and is an acceptable practice to avoid waste when it's managed in a proper way. This was an okay and ideal option for me and again, the quality/taste was great. I'm telling as many people as possible about Kincaids in Fishers. I'm so glad they're here!
-
May 2022 by Kevin Terstegge
Very friendly and helpful staff. I'll definitely be back
-
May 2022 by Sofia G.
I went in here to buy around 2 pounds of brisket for my father. As soon as I walked in I was greeted by a nice woman but another male worker behind the counter chimed in and asked me how many people I was serving. I told him two people, and told me the amount of meat I wanted "wasn't going to be enough" very rudely. I didn't appreciate this comment because he did not know what I was going to cook with the brisket, nor was that any of his business. (We planned on grinding up the meat with several other cuts to make hamburgers) I honestly thought about walking out after that and buying it somewhere else but the lady ended up cutting the brisket for me and didn't make any rude comments towards me. Unless you're going to buy like 10-20 pounds of a certain meat I wouldn't recommend going in here because they will probably be put off by your requests. Definitely won't be back because this wasn't my first unpleasant experience here.
-
May 2022 by Lee S.
The best meat purveyor in town. Perfectly sliced and layered hard to find Serrano ham. Service workers are knowledgeable, efficient and pleasant....even fun. Top grades of all meat protein options. The quality is unmatched in the greater Indy metropolitan area. Primarily a fresh meat shop but does have frozen options.
