-
December 2023 by Shaina Stahl
Been coming here for 10+ years now, and this place never fails to disappoint. Staff is friendly and helpful, the store is well organized and has lots of variety. Good location too, very close to Castleton mall. I’ve seen lots of businesses in this area come and go, but this place is always here. Highly recommend for comic lovers.
-
December 2023 by Christian Allison
The store has a great selection of comics and variant covers. I have been here several times already. The worker answered my questions and explained how their website worked for their pull list. I would recommend this place to anybody looking for comics.
-
December 2023 by krystahl brown
Just wanted to say been going to this comic book store since i was growing up and today and the past of a couple times made me realize i need to order online or find a new comic book store because the man Thats always there is rude as hell for no reason wants to give attitude when you are there to pick up comics. I just love being there to be checked out for 40 mins because he just wants to stand and talk to someone just for fun not moving the line ahead but he has the attitude when he causes the problems.
-
November 2023 by Rebecca Hall
Pretty good comic book selection! Some board games and TCG, but mainly comics. Staff were chill and helpful.
-
November 2023 by Ben Wolfe
Nice, inviting folks who engage their customers. Great selection.
-
October 2023 by Ryan Dorfmeyer
Came in for the first time a couple weeks ago searching for some new releases. Experience was great. Seemed like a good shop. Found everything I was looking for. Price was ok. Guy behind the counter was nice enough. Lots of choices for kids in the front of shop. TCG, Funkos and other collectibles are featured here as well.
-
September 2023 by Jen G
I’ve been coming here for over 20 years. Love Pete, Mike and Doug —
-
July 2023 by The Epic Girl Gamer
Very good comic selection, I usually go in and only buy sonic the hedgehog issues and they always have a good supply of them. Whenever I do pick up something else tho it is very easy to find, good store layout! All cashiers I've talked too have been very helpful and kind, will continue shopping at this business for years to come :)
-
July 2023 by Ada “Ashkat” Ashkar
This comic store is full of good quality (vintage and new,) good priced comics. They also have funko pops, games, and much more. Its perfect for all ages and is really a great place to go.
-
June 2023 by A K
Went into the store on a day where I just wanted to chill because I had nothing to do. I always check out comic book stores when I find a new one. Walked in the guy stared at me for 5 mins so I said hi no response.Walked pass the register the guy acted like I was going to rob him or something. Felt awkward so I said hi again no response. Walked around look at comics felt uncomfortable so I left he didn’t say anything to me the whole time I was there until I walked close to the register only for the guy to say “do you need help finding anything…” I hate to leave bad reviews but like come on.I don’t know if this place is always like this or if you just don’t like when there is only a POC person and you working in the store. As a place for nerds and comic book lovers you sure don’t make us feel comfortable.
-
December 2022 by Joe K.
Absolutely the best comic shop in Indianapolis! Props to the downtown store, of course, but I LOVE the Castleton store!!
-
September 2022 by Lothran
Guy working was so rude. He acted like anything I asked him, I was interrupting his lean on the counter time. I asked 2 questions that only he would be able to answer about the availability of two specific comics.Comic Carnival is 100x better. Both selection and service.
-
July 2022 by Ethan A.
One of my favorite comic stores here in Indiana! It is also the perfect place to check out Free Comic Book Day annually!
-
December 2021 by Len L.
I enjoy visiting different cities comic book stores such as DT Comic North, the store is organized well and what I enjoy the most is the back issues selections that I missed in the past. The customer service was awesome as they gave me what I asked for and their own opinion on what they thought, which is what I value from that. There are parking in the lot and always a friendly smile when you leave.
-
December 2021 by Linda Smith
I was given a comic collection and knew nothing about them. I went here first for some sort of education and value. Two men took, at max, 15 minutes to look through 798 comics and then offered me $500 for the lot. I said I had another appointment and was told if I left they would have to look them over again and that would somehow be an extra burden. I went to Comic Carnival and Tim Reynolds took 3 1/2 hours valuing each comic with an offer almost 3 times what these rip off guys did. Don’t ever go to this store - fast buck, bilk the ignorant customer.
