-
November 2023 by Jeff Hasser
Have been a loyal customer for years. They are quick and have kept my car running great. I stopped working downtown and still take my car into them.
-
November 2023 by R Strong
Brought my H3 in because it was making a serious knocking noise. Turned out to be my drive shaft. Dropped my truck off at 11am, got a call at noon telling me it's one of two things if not both. They were able to replace the drive shaft and it turned out that is all that needed to be replaced. Had my truck back by 3:30p the same day!!! Highly recommend and will be a repeat customer, but hopefully not often lol
-
November 2023 by James B.
Low quality men that run this shop. Scammers. Over charging for parts, overcharging for labor. They tried to charge me $1250 total to change my brake pads and a single rotor. That's insanity. These are the types of guys who try to take advantage of naive people. Stay away from these scum bags
-
November 2023 by Mike H
Great people, great service. I’ve been taking all four of my vehicles there for a couple of years now, after a pretty horrible experience with a different downtown Indy shop. I couldn’t be happier with their entire way of doing business.
-
October 2023 by Yusra O
I came here in crisis because my car urgently needed new tires, but I love this place. They do high quality reliable work. When I get an oil change they always check my brakes, battery etc as well.
-
October 2023 by Justin Rowland
Great and friendly service. Pricing seemed fair, but I've only been in once so far. I plan on going back for both our cars in the future.
-
September 2023 by Julia Gorin
If you’re a woman or any naive looking girl, be prepared for the robbery of your life!! Asked for an oil change and instead got charged $500 for things I never asked for and services that shouldn’t have cost more than $50. Please please please do your research or come with a guy that knows about cars so you don’t get robbed like I did. Especially as a broke college student paying for my own tuition and rent, this was definitely a learning lesson for me.
-
September 2023 by Julia G.
If you're a girl, or anyone naive looking DONT GO HERE. Tested my luck, brought it my car for an oil change, guys at the front were super cool and helpful untill I got charged $450 for an OIL CHANGE. Granted, it was my fault for falling for it but I was tired and confused and they were so nice I didn't want to cause a scene. They replaced a ton of stuff I never asked them to do, charged me insane amounts for every little thing, and I: a broke college student: got robbed into paying almost $500 for an oil change and new battery (which I never asked for). I have learned my lesson but I hope you guys don't have to loose half a grand to learn yours.
-
August 2023 by Mattie Manning
Shop (8/23/23) was pretty unprofessional towards my wife after she asked them why the price was soooo drastically different from what she had talked to before dropping off her car. Seems like this shop likes to prey on female customers and do not recommend them after our experience.
-
August 2023 by alan kilbarger
My daughter had an issue with her car. AAA towed it to All Star Tire for repair. It was closest location that AAA recommended. The verbal estimate was $150-$300 on a Friday. On Monday she was given a written estimate over $3,000! We decided to tow it to another shop for their feedback. The second shop estimated $435 and we moved ahead with them to complete the work. A day later a check engine light came on. Upon inspection there were components that All Star Tire did NOT reinstall correctly. The repair did not require this component to be touched. The second shop had to re-install components that All Star Tire removed during their initial diagnostic work. All Star Tire did not re-install parts correctly and the second shop had to compete the work and charge us a fee. I met with All Star Tire and shared the bills with them. They did not take responsibility for their technicians errors. They blamed me for towing the car away from their shop. All Star Tire would not reimburse me for the bill that I had to pay to complete the component assembly they did NOT complete. Please avoid this shop. They do not take responsibility for their technicians if an error is made and they quote work that is excessive. We contacted AAA to let them know All Star Tire should not be a recommended shop.
-
August 2023 by Michael Zaug
Hit a pot hole in Indy on a road trip and blew out a tire. They replaced it quickly and efficiently with an inexpensive one that will get us through our trip. Really friendly staff and no upsell involved. Highly recommend them.
-
August 2023 by Michael Z.
We hit a pot hole in Indianapolis that blew out our tire on a trip back to the Midwest from New York. We had the tow truck take us here and we were very impressed with their knowledge and quality of service. They got us an inexpensive replacement tire that will get us through our trip and did not try to upsell us. Also the work was done astonishingly quickly, like 45 minutes. If I lived in the area, I would definitely use them.
-
July 2023 by Kaan CANKIRI
Came in to change brakes system entirely, oil and tire rotations. Great price for quality work!Fantastic service, thank you Chris every time I brought my car in the service was quick and efficient. They are honest with their work and are not looking to scam you out of thousands of dollars for a simple fix.
-
June 2023 by Darin Larimore
Shady shop, insurance parts not installed properly on my wife’s car. Photo shows a catalytic bracket left disconnected which caused it to flex and eventually crack at the header connection.They are overpriced, slow, and we ended up with a botched job.I’d give All star… a one star.
-
May 2023 by Chelsea Doyle
Soo nice and got me in right away, knew what was wrong and fixed it within a half hour. I have never had such a great experience with a tire company!! Family owned too which I love.
