David Key: Allstate Insurance is a well-regarded agency located in the Evansville area. With experience as an insurance agent since 2006, David takes pride in helping clients and his team achieve their goals. The agency is committed to giving back to the community, supporting organizations like Holly’s House, YMCA of Southwestern Indiana, and St. Jude Children's Hospital. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable and compassionate staff, who provide excellent service and clear communication. Many clients have noted the ease of switching to Allstate, with significant savings on home, auto, and business insurance. The agency offers a user-friendly online site and is available Monday through Friday, along with after-hours service. David and his team have been praised for their quick responses and thorough answers, particularly in handling claims for storm damage. Clients feel supported and stress-free, knowing their concerns are taken seriously. Overall, David Key: Allstate Insurance is recognized for its outstanding customer service and dedication to clients.
David was amazing in helping me set up a plan for exactly what I needed. Very patient with all of my questions, made sure I understood things that I was unaware of, additions/ subtractions to the contract and more questions. Very Excited to work with them!
December 2025
He is friendly and willing to explain what you need.
November 2025
Definitely recommend going through David key directly went to Allstate in general for my car insurance. I was paying over $130 switched to David Key and now I’m paying 99 and some change.
