Casey's in Dyer, IN offers a convenient one-stop shop with quality gasoline, a wide selection of snacks and drinks, and surprisingly delicious made-from-scratch pizza and other hot food options. Customers consistently praise the friendly, helpful staff, especially the manager Erica who is described as "absolutely amazing" and always bringing a "positive vibe and cheerful" attitude. The reviews highlight Casey's as a great place to get gas, coffee, snacks, and lottery tickets, with the added bonus of exceptional customer service that makes the experience even more enjoyable. Customers feel welcomed from the moment they walk through the door, and the staff work hard to ensure everything runs smoothly, even during busy times. Several reviewers note that this particular Casey's location stands out, with one stating it's the one "where I feel many of the customers, most definitely including myself, feel the most welcome." The pizza in particular is called out as being "WAAAYYYYY better than most takeout/delivery pizza places around Dyer and St. John." Overall, Casey's in Dyer provides a reliable one-stop shop with high-quality products and outstanding service that leaves customers feeling satisfied and eager to return.
Lazy employee, Always have nasty attitude. Won’t shop there again!!
January 2024
Not really sure what’s going on with my pizza or how it can be multiple different sizes if they weren’t pulled from other pizzas. I feel like for the price it better be able to compare to places nearby. For as much hype as the pizza here gets and my previous experiences with other Casey’s I was a bit let down.
December 2023
The manager Erica is absolutely amazing. Always brining a positive vibe and cheerful. Erica always goes above and beyond everytime i see her. Return customer for that alone.
