Casey's in Cedar Lake, IN, is a popular spot for pizza, snacks, and everyday essentials. Known for its made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings, the pizza is considered a favorite among customers. Whether ordering for delivery or pickup, the pizzas are always on point, with many noting the friendly service and consistent quality. The staff is described as nice, friendly, and attentive, making sure customers get what they want. Besides pizza, the store offers appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and groceries, making it a convenient place to stop for various needs. The gas station part of Casey's has mixed reviews. While some appreciate the convenience and the ability to use Fuelman, others mention issues like pumps frequently being out of receipt paper and pumps often being broken. Customers note that the store is not very modern, and the food quality is typical gas station fare. Prices for gas fluctuate, but discounts are sometimes available through apps like Upside. Employees are generally friendly, but some customers feel they focus more on gossiping than providing quick service. The location is accessible, with clean bathrooms and friendly gestures towards kids and customers with disabilities. Parking is available, and the store is generally clean enough for a quick stop. Overall, Casey's is valued for its good pizza and convenient location, despite some minor issues with the gas station operations.
I dont know this person's name but they gave me great customer service it was a boy blonde hair made by pizza at 727 PM
June 2025
Getting pizzas from Casey's in Cedar Lake is always a delightful experience! Whether their pepperoni, sausage, cheese, or ham and mushrooms (my personal favorite) their pizzas are always our go-to. Amy and Bill are always nice and friendly, and always make sure we get what we want and make sure pizzas are always on point🤌🏻😋
June 2023
Overall, not a bad gas station. They take Fuelman. However, they tend to close 3-5 minutes earlier than their posted close time and the new fuel pumps tend to be broken half the time. Then again, it's the lesser of the two gas stations in this town.
