-
September 2024 by Frances J. Jenson
Drove 7mi one way to save 25 cents per gallon only to find the price was same as first town and no lower price available. Bummer!
-
September 2024 by tyler tigner
I come here quite often, and most of the time customer service is decent, food is hit or miss. But what really bothers me is how they hide the food expiration times, and they are never open when they say they are open. It says hours were confirmed by the business a week ago, well how is this morning they aren’t open yet and it’s been an hour? This is consistent with a trend of the last 6 months( as long as I’ve lived here). Corporate needs to come down and give the store manager, a talking too, and more frequent health inspections.
-
September 2024 by C A
Refuse to make a sub even though they're standing around... subway it is.
-
August 2024 by Jilly Smith
Stopped in for a fill up on fuel and a quick bite. Picked out the new pulled pork sliders. Highly recommended. You get 3 to a package. Just the right amount to toss down while on our bike trip. Friendly service and nice customers too.
-
June 2024 by Spenser Overton
Says open at 4 am. Not open and doesnt answer the phone
-
January 2024 by Mike Elmore
Ordered pizza and breadsticks on the phone. Got to the station and all of the employees were cheery and helpful. The food was very good.
-
November 2023 by Zachary
Overall good food, breakfast pizza is top notch.I wish the donuts/pastries had less frosting, seems like everything is coated in something.
-
October 2023 by Heidi M.
Great local gas station with very friendly customer service employees! Great rewards program! Pizza is always amazing!
-
October 2023 by Tessa Carter
This is a gas station.
-
October 2023 by Mav Gutwein
2/18/23 7pm they r closed?!?!
-
June 2023 by Janet Pippin
Both female cashiers when we came were VERY rude and not polite. One threatened to give a customer a black eye and making fun of him not being able to pump gas. Clean facility though.
-
June 2023 by Mrs. Lisa Romano
This is a really great gasoline station , Hot pizza, Sub sand sandwiches, Just about everything you could ever need.
-
March 2023 by Skettiohs Yum
Dana can wrap my burrito any day!
-
January 2023 by Abigale Gettinger
We love Casey's breakfast pizza. But if you are there before 8 am on a Sat, don't bank on them having any available. This is the only Casey's that I've been to that won't start making pizza early. The donuts were stocked, and there were 2 burritos at 745 am. I asked how long for pizza, and she said 10 minutes and said they don't start making pizza til 8 on the weekend.... the staff is always incredibly friendly, the place was clean. But if you're known for the breakfast pizza, I would plan on having that out by 6 am. Especially on a Saturday with all the hunters and blue collar workers we have. Seems like a missed opportunity for sales. Guess we'll keep traveling down the road to find a Casey's that wants breakfast pizza sales.
-
January 2023 by bec boller
Ok this is one of the best pizzas in the area and who would of thought it would come from a gas station. But I had an experience last night that was totally my fault I called the Monticello Casey’s ordered my pizza went to Brookston and picked up the wrong pizza causing the staff all kinds of chaos and they could not have been nicer about it when I was totally at fault and the Monticello Casey’s called me and they weren’t thrilled but they weren’t real happy but they understood accidents happen so overall I love Casey’s pizza
