Casey's in Brookston, IN is a convenient one-stop shop offering a variety of services and products. Their made-from-scratch pizza with real mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings is a customer favorite, along with their appetizers, sweet treats, and grocery items. The station also provides quality fuels to fill up your tank. While the customer service is generally decent, some reviews mention inconsistent food quality and issues with the store's hours of operation. The store is praised for its cleanliness, and the staff is described as friendly. However, there are concerns about the store's management, with one reviewer suggesting the need for more frequent health inspections. Despite these mixed reviews, Casey's remains a popular destination for local residents, offering a wide range of products and services to meet their everyday needs.
Drove 7mi one way to save 25 cents per gallon only to find the price was same as first town and no lower price available. Bummer!
August 2024
Stopped in for a fill up on fuel and a quick bite. Picked out the new pulled pork sliders. Highly recommended. You get 3 to a package. Just the right amount to toss down while on our bike trip. Friendly service and nice customers too.
January 2024
Ordered pizza and breadsticks on the phone. Got to the station and all of the employees were cheery and helpful. The food was very good.
