Casey's is a clean and convenient store known for its fresh food and pleasant staff. Many customers appreciate the quick access and the variety of snacks available. However, there are mixed reviews about the pizza orders; some customers frequently experience issues with incorrect orders, despite providing clear instructions. Breakfast pizza availability is also a concern, as it often runs out before 9am, which can be frustrating for parents. While some have praised the Taco Pizza and cheese breadsticks, others have reported disappointing experiences with the quality of ingredients. Overall, Casey's is a popular spot for quick visits, but there is room for improvement in service consistency and menu offerings.
This store location is always clean and convenient but they also ALWAYS mess up my pizza order. Doesn't matter if its door dashed or picked up ordered direct. Clear instructions - still always incorrect. Every. Single. Time. Extremely frustrating but still generally tasty, just not what I ordered - so 3 stars I guess.
December 2023
Have always bragged on Supreme Pizza & have had awesome cheese breadsticks. Tonight’s order was very disappointing. Don’t know if it was the cook or cheap ingredients.
November 2023
It's as good as you can get for a little gas station. Easy in and out off the roadway. Pleasant staff, clean restrooms, good place to stock up on snacks before leaving
