-
March 2023 by Micheal P.
I've been a customer ohhh,15+ years? Andy and his team have ALWAYS, shall I say awesome!?! But,having operated business, there are times when something happens less than ideal. It just does. I'd bought a watch,(Rolex) that later needed an overhaul. Quality fell short. Andy had been so good to me,I was just going to put it in a drawer,forget about it. Buy another one. Andy said send it back! This 60 year old watch is keeping perfect time,and he wouldn't let me pay. THAT'S why you buy from Andy and the gang,THANKS!!!
-
October 2022 by James R.
Amazing watch collections they have here.
-
September 2022 by Janet Clohecy
I'm not wealthy, but Andy was very helpful,patient and informative. Thank you!
-
December 2021 by Marc W.
I almost never post reviews of anyone or anything, but Andy at Old World was so great, I have to provide my endorsement. I was in the market for something special for my 50th and I was searching for the right pre-owned Panerai to come along. When I saw the right model posted for sale on eBay, always the skeptic, I immediately did my due diligence on Old World. Among other things, the reviews were stellar. I contacted Old World directly and asked for Andy. He was very accommodating, great communication and worked with me on the price to make the deal happen. I couldn't be happier with the transaction and the beautiful time piece. Andy will be my first call going forward for every high-end watch occasion. Thank you Andy and Old World!
-
December 2020 by J. Lewis
I never write reviews, but in this case I'll make an exception, because my experience was exception-al. I called Andy with interest in a watch they had, and almost immediately (though I had never heard of Old World Jewelers or Andy) I had a high level of comfort with our conversation and the specifics he was giving me. He took the time to check small details to my satisfaction and never tried to convince or sell - just helped me know everything I wanted to know so that I could decide the rest. He accommodated my transaction preferences and within hours the package was on the way. Upon receipt, everything was EXACTLY as we had discussed. No exceptions. Honesty and integrity are much harder to find these days than they should be, but you will find it here.
-
January 2020 by Heather Jewell
Absolutely wonderful service. I went here to sell estate jewelry and was given very personal attention and had no doubts about their honesty and reliability. I would recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell valuable items.
-
September 2019 by Jeff C.
Bought a Rolex from Andy for my wife's upcoming retirement. He had a good selection, was very knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful. The watches were reasonably priced and he was not "offended" when I asked if he could do a little better on the price of the one I ultimately chose. He made the whole buying experience quite enjoyable compared to the authorized Rolex dealers who act as though they are doing you a favor to sell you a watch. I dealt with Andy in person as I have a home in both the Chicago area and Florida. I look forward to doing more business with him in the future.
-
September 2019 by April R.
Old World Jewelers. Worth the drive to Wheaton Before my brother died he asked my husband and me to help his wife sell his watch collection. So we ended up with 90 luxury watches to sell, including 11 Rolexes, a couple of Patek Philippe's, many Omegas, and on and on. We looked up pre-owned watches on the internet and came up with three dealers who were highly reviewed on Yelp. The first dealer was only interested in the Rolexes and Patek Philippes. His offer seemed low. Another dealer was willing to take them all and willing to educate us on the watch business and watches in general, which was great, but his offer also seemed low. And then we went to Andy Olczak at Old World Jewelers. He spent a great deal of time with us, assessing every watch, and said he would definitely make an offer for many of the watches and could help us sell the rest through consignment at Old World. When he did make an offer, though, it was for the whole collection and it was significantly higher than what the other two jewelers had offered. Andy treated us well, offering advice as well as a fair amount for the watches we were selling. He was true to his word; he made an offer and that was what he ended up paying us; there were no last-minute adjustments. You can probably sell a Rolex or a Patek Philippe easily enough, but if you want top dollar or you have other brands of pre-owned watches to sell, take a drive to Wheaton and Old World Jewelers. By the way, all of the jewelers spotted fakes among my brother's collection. Beware. It seems that making fake luxury watches is a big business. Only buy from someone you think you can trust, such as Old World Jewelers, and consider an appraisal if the watch price is significant.
-
August 2018 by Jim Pucci
I had several watches to sell...I called Andy and made an appointment and went to see him.Ron came into our conversation and I left with having a very satisfactory experience.His offers were fair and I felt very comfortable with our transaction.Both men are very knowledgeable and professional.Ive known Ron for many years and he has a terrific reputation.Well Done Old World Jewelers!!!
-
July 2018 by Rich K
Andy and Tina provided me with super friendly service and were willing to spend the time to answer all my questions in detail. One of the best customer service experiences I've had. They're professionals with decades of experience, BBB accreditation, and almost 2000 positive transactions on ebay. I found a Rolex I liked on their ebay page, called their shop, and they made the entire process a cinch, had the watch the next day here in Florida. Buy with confidence from these class act professionals!
-
April 2018 by Roy H.
Extremely comfortable accommodating and private.
-
February 2018 by Sandi S
Andy and his business are sure in a league of their own...we are hotel owners and got in touch with "Old World Jewelers" regarding a Rolex - Submariner....the manner in which he treated us and the level of Honesty and Integrity whether one is able to do business with them or not was truly wonderful...other business owners could learn from Andy!
-
April 2017 by Cody Kazan
I recently had the pleasure of working with Andy on the selling and buying of a watch and it was an excellent experience. Andy was honest, effficient, communicative and an absolute pleasure to do business with. I will not go anywhere else for my next watch/jewelery transaction. Thanks Andy! Thanks Old World Jewelers!!!
-
November 2016 by Jonathan Huard
I've purchased two Rolex's from Andy at Old World in the last year, while trading in my used watches each time. Both experiences were great and he was very fair with the trade in values. I'd highly recommend giving them a try if you don't want to go to the standard retailers and pay much higher prices.
