-
February 2024 by Helmut Muller
Some reviewers here claim the staff is rude. That was not my experience. I found them all very polite and helpful. I was also impressed that on a Saturday morning the place was filled with customers. This seems to be a gathering place for Peoria's small numismatic community.
-
December 2023 by April McGee
It's a great place and the people are very friendly and helpful. I want to say it's family ran.
-
December 2023 by Gary McCullough
The integrity and professionalism is above reproach. The honesty of those there draws my attention and business!
-
November 2023 by Matthew Behnke
Have Purchased a few times from here, always friendly. And the amount of items here is amazing. Will bb making more purchases here.
-
September 2023 by Anson Light
5 star, all the way. I just sold some gold and silver jewelry. I checked around before selling, thinking I'd probably sell via mail to a refinery. No need to deal with that hassle, Wendy's offer was that good. I walked out within 10 minutes, and was paid $250-$300 more than I was quoted at other places. Literally twice the cash in my pocket versus one of the local pawn shops were offering.I can't recommend them enough!Thanks!
-
July 2023 by Roland Campbell
Great store with a huge selection. If you collect ANYTHING, check out Wendy's!
-
May 2023 by Douglas A Stewart
Wendy is very nice and fair in purchasing items! The entire staff is a pleasure to see and deal with as well. You can't go wrong with Wendy!!
-
April 2023 by Tom Patterson
I've been there many times before buying coins and my family has bought ? Bears and other collectibles,but I just got off the phone with the rudest guy, first time he hung up on me then I called again and got to the point and said can you tell me if my coins have increased in value. He said bring them in.
-
February 2023 by Nsncy Schaffner
This store was very clean and well organized. The prices were reasonable for quality items. The staff was very friendly and informative about the background of the store. I will be go back again and again.
-
December 2022 by Collin Krause
Pretty unfriendly experience. The staff doesn’t acknowledge you. I walked in today looking for a specific type of quarter. The cashier handed me a box full of quarters and barked at me to look through them on the counter like I was going to try and steal his ungraded poor-quality quarters. I just handed the box back and walked out.
-
November 2022 by Lulu L.
I had the daunting task of liquidating a large coin collection from across the country while knowing nothing about coins. I needed someone local who could appraise the collection and guide me through the process of selling the coins. After blindly talking with several coin specialists who wreaked of deception (I told a friend that I felt like I was swimming with sharks), I learned of the Professional Numismatists Guild. Thankfully, I found Gerald "Jerry" Scherer from their directory. Jerry is the numismatist at Wendy's Creative Collection and Coins and owner of The Numismatic Net Worth Company. Jerry organized and appraised the large collection and consulted with me on all matters of liquidating the collection. Jerry was knowledgable, helpful and honest. He was just a lovely person to work with. Honestly, I don't know what I would have done without him. I will add that the valuation of the very large coin collection done by the major reputable auction house I ended up selling the coins to and Jerry's appraisal were remarkable close. Although I didn't go to him with the purpose of selling or buying coins, I would happily complete any coin transaction with Jerry with the utmost confidence in his integrity and knowledge.
-
October 2022 by Xxxx Ooo
I’ve sold some surplus items from my collection over the years and Wendy always offered a fair price.
-
June 2022 by Abbie Alexander
Wendy and staff have been wonderful for 30+ years. She checks "spot" for the best price and allows us to buy scrap from her. I am sure she has saved me thousands over the years. I highly recommend her business.
-
June 2022 by Quade Monagle
This was my first time in a coin shop and I had a great experience! Friendly staff and a great selection. I will definitely be back.
-
February 2022 by Amy Jo Irions
This team made it so easy to sell jewelry!! Very smooth process and very fair prices on used a used ring set and fast. Thank you!
