-
April 2024 by Feki Pouha
The breakfast pizza was good as well as the breakfast sandwiches and scramble.
-
May 2023 by Spencer H.
If I could leave it a zero star I would. We went to the store at 4 PM and ordered five large pizzas and two orders of breadsticks to be ready at 6 PM so that we could feed our two families.We returned at 6 PM and were told that they had gotten a large order in just after ours and were behind and that our order was going to be another 30 minutes out. That seemed odd to us, because the orders that come in afterwards should really not have impacted our orders and the timeliness of it. It was disappointing but stuff happens.At 6:30 we returned to the store and we received mumbled excuses and were told that it will be another 20 minutes. It was a really awkward weird situation. No clear communication.We left and returned at 6:50. The girl behind the pizza bar told us that our breadsticks were in the oven and that she was prepping the dough for our five pizzas right then. We couldn't believe it. There was no time for us to wait and eat because of other evening appointments. We told them that we needed to cancel the order. The girl turned to her coworker and said, "oh, this is great. This is even easier." They were not sorry in the least bit and we were taken aback by the lack of customer service, the lack of management, and the complete lack of an apology for messing up this evening meal.We won't go hungry, we live in a first world country, but it was shocking to experience this kind of lack of management and customer service. Absolutely unreal.
-
April 2023 by Erin P.
Amazed this little Casey's had gas AND pizza in the warmer.
-
April 2023 by Mike S.
Ordered a pizza online whilst visiting the local sites. It was fast and freshly made. It's about the only option for lunch in the town at this time of year. It was fast and the people are friendly.
-
April 2023 by Ben Barlow
Pizza - 3 stars - really chewy. Smells better than it tastesWings - 3 stars - not great. Almost taste like an attempt at fried chicken. No sauces provided..Not having to drive 30 minutes for food - PRICELESS! - after having been in Nauvoo for four days it is refreshing to get food so close to where we are staying. I’m sure these guys do a ton of business in the summer
-
March 2023 by Ben B.
Pizza - 3 stars - really chewy. Smells better than it tastesWings - 3 stars - not great. Almost taste like an attempt at fried chicken. No sauces provided..Not having to drive 30 minutes for food - PRICELESS! - after having been in Nauvoo for four days it is refreshing to get food so close to where we are staying. I'm sure these guys do a ton of business in the summer!
-
March 2023 by Zander Thompson
Best place for a drink plus the workers are great
-
August 2022 by Bennett Vaterlaus
A respectable establishment whose 'Star rating' does not do justice for. $2.99 for a single filling slice.
-
August 2022 by Jan Bishop
I didn’t have the pizza, but I went in to buy a bottle of Diet Coke. No bottles of Diet Coke. In fact, the store kinda looked like a zombie apocalypse had hit. This was the middle of the day on a Monday.
-
March 2022 by Ethan Lynn
Two words: tasty pizza.There's not much to eat in the area, and this Casey's delivers some quality pizza. I make it a point to stop here when visiting.
-
June 2021 by Jacob Sowards
Terrible service. Went in to get a snack for the kids and couldn't even get the employee to pay attention to me so I could make a purchase.
-
June 2021 by Tim Wardlow
How to get a 1 star review: run out of ketchup packets and act d*** when I suggest you open a bottle of ketchup from off the shelf
-
March 2021 by KINGDAVE!
One of the best Donuts ever and great pizza!
-
October 2020 by doublerose ranch
It's casey's!!
-
November 2019 by deborah worden
Our family loves making our traditional annual autumn trip to Nauvoo. We’ve been enjoying Sunday brunch in autumn at Hotel Nauvoo for 65 years now! After the perfect meal at Hotel Nauvoo we toured the homes in this historic, beautiful town, & then drove along the river, & back, before the 75 mile return drive home. We stopped at this local Casey’s to purchase gas, treats, & bottled water, before the long drive home. We asked the young blonde woman behind the counter if we could use the restroom facilities before heading home. The young lady told us we weren’t allowed to use their public restroom, & told us to go down the street to “Dollar General” and “maybe” Dollar General would allow us to use their restroom. This remark, after we paid good money to buy gas and products at Casey’s. We would have returned to Hotel Nauvoo, but being a Sunday, the Hotel closed at 2 PM. We asked this young lady – what do staff do if they have to use the restroom facilities? The young lady told us staff are allowed to use the restroom there. I told her because we were paying customers we too should be allowed to use the restroom. She then told us their public toilet didn’t work, & leaks water all over the floor, adding they won’t allow customers use of their public restroom for fear we customers will slip on the water, and injure ourselves. This young lady did not greet us when we entered Casey’s, there were no other customers in the building, but one other staff woman behind the food prep area. This young lady looked at us and said “is this all you want?” We paid the young lady for our gas, treats, & bottled water, and thanked her, however this young lady said absolutely nothing. No “thank you”. She was rude and it was obvious she was bored standing there behind the counter. Never have we received such a reception in the beautiful town of Nauvoo. Truly, everyone we have always met in this wonderful sacred place has been loving, and even though we are strangers we have always felt welcome. We feel fortunate that in the 65 years we’ve visited Nauvoo we never met a person like this, until Sunday, at Casey’s. We don’t know this young lady’s name because she was not wearing a name tag. A simple greeting of “hello”, & those 2 words “thank you”, mean the world to us. Perhaps Casey’s could hire someone who is pleasant with a good work ethic.
