Casey's in Nauvoo, IL is a convenient one-stop shop that offers a variety of services and products. The pizza, made with fresh ingredients and scratch-made dough, is a customer favorite, though some have found it to be a bit chewy. The wings, while not exceptional, provide a quick and easy snack option. The store is well-run, with friendly and helpful staff, though one customer encountered an employee who seemed inconvenienced by their order. Overall, Casey's is praised for its ability to meet the needs of the local community, whether it's fueling up, grabbing a coffee, or picking up household essentials. The location is particularly appreciated by those visiting Nauvoo, as it provides a convenient dining option close to their accommodations.
I can't believe I'm giving gas station pizza 5 stars but here I am. It wasn't amazing pizza by any means, but it was cheap and done on time!
July 2025
Ordered our food and paid online but it never showed up here, but the lady behind the counter got it going and we had it after not too long a wait. Food definitely helped in a pinch and service was friendly and helpful.
June 2025
Casey's is a great convenience store! Their service is fantastic & the pizza is quite good too! They are great!
