Casey's in Metamora is a 24-hour gas station and convenience store known for its pizza delivery and pickup. The pizza features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The location offers a variety of other fresh food, appetizers, sweet treats like donuts, snacks, drinks, groceries, and household essentials. It is described as always being open, helpful, and a place to get what is needed at any hour. The store is noted for being always clean and having kind, nice staff. It has a lot of parking and is wheelchair accessible. There is a lot of variety in snacks and food, with some vegetarian options and dietary items available. However, some reviewers note that the food quality, especially pizza, has dropped, with complaints of undercooked or badly made pizzas. The location also has recurring problems, with gas pumps and receipt printers often out of order, and issues with the rewards system and credit card readers being down. While helpful for late-night needs, it is noted as a gas station and not a place to hang out with kids.
Casy's is my childhood but I wish you guys kept the icecream machine i miss it so much and the pizza is perfect with extra sauce and cheese!
February 2024
Pizza was not cut all the way through we ordered a taco pizza and the Doritos were stale otherwise everything else was
September 2022
Nice staff, always have liked caseys but the food quality has dropped tremendously. We don't eat pizza from here anymore after repeated partially undercooked or Badly made pizzas. Too much money wasted
