-
April 2024 by Cally Dennis
We went in with 6 kids and 4 adults. The service was super quick and the food, exceptional! Who ever thought of putting pepperoni on a BLT is my new hero! Amazing!!!
-
January 2024 by Joe Snyder
Great
-
January 2024 by Melissa Toone
Everything here is amazing, this is our favorite Papa Kelsey's in Idaho. I will always recommend them! ?
-
November 2023 by Eric F
They usually give generous helpings of ice cream. We mostly get the single scoop. Very satisfying.
-
November 2023 by Tori Beth Pilcher
I’m a celiac. It is really hard for me to find pizza where I don’t get cross contamination. The pizza was delicious! It was only a $2 up charge for the gf crust (I’ve paid more). It was really great to be able to enjoy a pizza without anxiety.
-
November 2023 by G RAThbun
It is a clean, quiet, and delicious place to eat.
-
September 2023 by Albert Jeszke
Quick service and friendly staff, even as 7 of us came in a short time before closing!
-
September 2023 by Benjamin Presley
Traveling across the country, I stopped in Hagerman, Papa Kelley's was open and had a moderate crowd so I checked it out.. the service was a little slow but with 3 people holding it down they did a great job and the food was great, with a reasonable price.
-
September 2023 by Chad Dunford
Really solid pizza. Good timely service. I'd recommend it.
-
September 2023 by Pst Taylor
It was a to-go order with extra crispy onion rings and they came out uncooked it all and it was a to-go order so I guess they don't care about if it's to go they just cook it
-
September 2023 by Ed Whitley
Nice little place, plenty of indoor seating and a small patio area out front with 4 or 5 small tables. Big menu with pizza, sandwiches, wings, and some other things, and priced reasonably for the current inflation. Took about 40 min to get 2 large and 1 mini pizza, but they were very good, would go again.
-
August 2023 by edmondite
We came here twice, once for ice cream and once to pick up pizza for dinner. Both were very good and we got quick friendly service!
-
August 2023 by Brian Rich
In Full disclosure, I didnt eat here, but the people I was with did.They all had icecream.I do want to say that this Papa Kelsey's is far better than the one in Wendell. This pertains to the atmosphere as well as to the icecream. If your in the Wendell area and want to go out, head on over to Hagerman.
-
July 2023 by Scott Richardson
Waited 45 minutes for eat in pizza. When we finally went to the counter to check on status, they said they forgot it was eat in so it was sitting there for a long time. Pizza quality and taste was similar to Digornios frozen pizza - very little sauce and cheese. Soda machine was out of ice and carbonation. Overall, a very disappointing experience.
-
July 2023 by Jeremy Bergeson
We ordered two subs and two personal pizza. All fabulous. Good bread. Good dough. Good ingredients. Very tasty.
