Papa Jay's is a popular spot in Cache Valley known for its delicious food and wide variety of beef jerky flavors. Customers praise the friendly and helpful staff, who provide quick and attentive service. The menu offers good home-cooked options, including the recommended pepper popper roast beef sandwich. Their jerky is highly acclaimed, with many saying it is the best they have ever tasted, especially the teriyaki and original flavors. The store is a great place for a small lunch and also features a simple geocache, adding to its charm. Overall, Papa Jay’s is loved for its tasty food, amazing jerky, and welcoming atmosphere.
Glad I stopped, the jerky was incredibly flavorful. Not a lot goes a long way.
August 2024
Damn good jerky and really good food! They have just about everything that you need.. The employees are so awesome and the owners are simply amazing.. Love ya Rich & Mary!!!
May 2024
Great little shop with excellent jerky, food & service!
