The American Eagle Store receives praise for its friendly and helpful staff, who are described as pleasant, attentive, and dedicated to providing excellent customer service. Employees are noted for going above and beyond to assist with transactions like returns, making customers feel welcomed and valued rather than like just another shopper. The atmosphere is often cheerful, with staff creating a great and enjoyable experience. The store offers a decent selection with quality items, particularly highlighted for having great jeans for all sizes that feature comfortable stretch material. The store layout is also considered fine. However, a significant drawback noted is a perceived lack of size inclusivity in the store's inventory, with a focus on smaller waist sizes that can feel exclusive and frustrating for customers seeking larger sizes. The retailer's rewards system is viewed positively, though some customers express a desire for past promotions and discounts to return. Overall, the staff's outstanding service is a consistent highlight, with customers hoping such efforts receive proper recognition from management.