-
December 2023 by Amy Wormley
What an amazing local gem! We booked a weekend stay and I can't wait to come back for longer. Family owned, friendly service. So much thoughtful detail has gone into the property and rooms. Each room has its own theme. Beds were comfortable and the rooms were very clean. Resort has its own private beach on the baybwhere you can kayak, etc. Quiet, relaxing weekend. Highly recommend!
-
November 2023 by Sydney Bartell
Such a gem! My husband and I spent a few days here and absolutely fell in love with this place. It’s calm, quiet, and a beautiful place to relax for a few days. Resort has charcoal barbecues, kayaks, paddle boards, lawn games, and plenty of comfortable seating for lounging.
-
November 2023 by Christie Remillard
We really needed a weekend getaway even though we are Floridians! lol The cottage provided all the essentials down to the coffee and toaster for our bagels. It was so relaxing and quiet it felt like we were the only people there! The property is meticulously kept! We are definitely making it a frequent getaway. The only thing I wish they had was a firepit to sit around
-
October 2023 by Chris Peskar
My husband & I loved celebrating our anniversary at Island Bay Resort.What a well-run, intimate resort with very clean cottages. Beautiful Landscaping. Paddleboards & kayaks. We enjoyed sitting on the dock with a cocktail for sunset. The resort has a very nice beach with chairs, hammocks & outside showers. The owners are very accommodating & hospitable.
-
October 2023 by liz W
Tropical, private resort with lots of vegetation and whimsical decorations. Each cottage is unique. There are only 20 people who can stay at a time and the beach has plenty of space for all of them to be comfortable. You cannot beat the sunset views from the beach. The resort is quiet, immaculately maintained, and has lots of outdoor areas to relax. We will be staying here again if we come back to the keys!
-
October 2023 by David Earp
The Island Bay Resort is the perfect place to get away from it all, forget life, and to relax and enjoy. It's quiet, peaceful, the rooms are updated and clean, and beautiful sunset views from the private beach. The service was great and friendly. The resort is obviously well ran. We will be back!
-
October 2023 by CAWagner51
We just left our Happy Place in The Keys and have to say that every time we go, I think we enjoy it more! We were a little apprehensive that the former owners had sold it and moved on, but the new owners are working diligently to maintain the character and integrity of this place. While we could very well spend our time at an elegant, new resort , we’d have to share the amenities with 200 plus people and children. By staying here, there will never be more than 18 other adults to share with. This place is RELAXING.. your own little private Trex deck, table, chairs and umbrella, a private bay beach, multiple furnishings for outside enjoyment. The cottages are old, but they are maintained well and have everything you need to be comfortable. Granted, they are small in size, but they offer ample storage space. Besides, you will not be in your room much AT ALL! We’d like to thank Austin for his assistance with a couple of minor issues. Our stay was very nice. PS: The entry gate, new to us, was much appreciated, and doing laundry in that sweet laundry room was a joy! Thank you Austin and Lauren.. Lola, and the housekeepers. Well done!
-
September 2023 by Amy Winters
We found a gem. This place was amazing. Clean, tropical, amazing sunsets. It was centrally located to drive and explore. Thanks y’all.
-
September 2023 by Derek Johnson
The uniquely themed guest cottages are perfect for a couple's getaway. The private waterfront and convenient location make this a wonderful destination in the Keys.
-
September 2023 by Trudy Meinecke
This was our 5th year coming here and we absolutely love it! The private drive with gate, beautiful beach, plenty of sitting areas, games and water toys, beautiful experiences of moon in morning off water, sunrises, and sunsets, is cozy cottages, accommodating cleaning staff, 2 cute resident dogs, and a lovely couple who own and manage the resort. Personal touches hard to find elsewhere. Only thing we miss is leaving our 8lb Shitzu at home for the week ?.
-
September 2023 by Jan DeProspero
If I could leave a 10 star review for Island Bay Resort I would! The resort was pristine to say the least. The cottages were quaint and well equipped! No detail seemed too small. There was always a hammock, lounge chair, kayak or paddleboard available for use. But the absolute BEST thing about Island Bay is it's people. The housekeeping staff was excellent and amenable to every request and Austin and Lauren went well out of their way to make my family feel at home! From the moment we arrived we felt like FAMILY! (To the point that I had to knock on their door after 9pm at night with an Asthma issue!!). I grew up in the Keys, most especially, the Islamorada area. I have stayed literally everywhere since my in-laws sold their home there and I can without reservation say I will not stay anywhere else again! I imagine people do not want to leave reviews because they don't want to let this secret little gem out to the rest of the world, believe me, that was my first thought too! There are a lot of beautiful places to stay and visit in the Keys but none that go out of their way to treat you as they would their very own family. Congratulations Austin and Lauren you have done an amazing job! The care and small thought out details you have crafted into this rare and special place really make is unique. Well Done guys, you should be very proud!!! I can't wait to stay there again and you are welcome in my home guest cottage anytime!! See you soon! Love Jan and family! <3Rooms: Quaint' unique, and all are a different theme! I noticed they are in order of the keys....Nearby activities: Rain Barrell gifts has a candle store that I never miss a stop at, she will mix the candles to the scent you like best, they are decorated in seascape motifs and best of all when you melt them they can be used as a lotion type body oil which is great for after a long day in the sun!Food & drinks: Lazy Days is the absolute best for lunch or dinner, be sure and go out on the dock to see the tarpon and nurse sharks that are always there. Harriets is wonderful for a home cooked breakfast and if you like something special try the Bacon, Egg, Brie and Jam on a Brioche at Midway Cafe!
-
August 2023 by Alice Marino
Love, Love, Love this beautiful Keys getaway. Perfect for couples. The rooms are quaint and lovely. And the property is impeccable and perfect in every way.Noteworthy details: Island Bay is a perfect, quiet couples getaway in the Florida Keys. It’s hard to fine a more lovely spot.
-
August 2023 by Ovid MC
This is a perfect romantic gateway for a couple. It’s quiet, private, and the sunsets are the best!!We spent 5 days here and it is our 3rd time. The owners are amazing and the staff is great. There are tons of wonderful restaurants close.
-
August 2023 by victoria ondo
It was a very nice place and beat all expectations. The rooms were clean and well kept. The all inclusive beach activities and nice beach were a great addition. 10/10 would recommend.
-
August 2023 by Tracy Mitchell
This was such a romantic getaway for a week. The rooms were designed beautifully; giving them a tropical paradise vibe, and the hospitality was EXCEPTIONAL! The private beach was just breath taking. Especially, when you capture some of the most beautiful sunsets I’ve ever seen. We have decided that this is going to be our very special place, and we will come back here every chance we get. We had so much fun on the paddle boats.Also, the restaurants and activities they recommended were amazing!I will telling my friends that Island Bay Resort is fantastic location for a romantic getaway or vacation. Lauren was very helpful, and all her staff wereaccommodating.We look forward to coming back for a weekend or another week adventure.
