Silvermill Plaza offers a variety of food options with generally positive reviews. The restaurant features tasty dishes like fajitas, sandwiches, and pastries such as Nutella cake. Customers appreciate the fresh and well-prepared food, especially the chicken fajitas and alcapurrias. The atmosphere is described as nice and fun, with some locations adding entertainment like a DJ and trivia nights. While most experiences are good, a few reviews mention minor issues; for example, a mix-up with fried mushrooms and jalapeño poppers was quickly acknowledged, and a sandwich wasn't prepared exactly as requested but was eventually corrected. Despite a fire that burned down their restaurant, the plaza still hosts other popular eateries, such as La Creation, known for Puerto Rican cuisine. Employees are often praised for their friendliness and helpfulness, making visits enjoyable even during difficult times. Overall, Silvermill Plaza provides good food and a lively environment.
Their pizza is great. Ordered fried mushrooms but got jalepeno poppers. Called to let them know and they wanted to make it right but I wanted to go to sleep! Great place
February 2025
Cody's (pictured) is long gone, burned to the ground a year ago. West shore Pizza is worth while
July 2024
The Silvermill Plaza restaurant burnt down. But La Creation still the best place in the plaza. Puerto Rican cuisine at its best.
