-
April 2024 by justin salt
BEWARE! I have been buying a selling for many years and this place is close to being pawn shop you will pay more but more importantly you will get ripped off selling. I have sold or tried to sell to them three times, once was a coin that they offered $300 for and I sold for $1800 to other dealer and twice with bullion which they would only pay 4 under spot ( I had bought it from them). I literally went to another dealer downtown and sold it for 1 under spot 10 minutes later. Do your homework.
-
March 2024 by Kyle Miller
Nice guys. Nicer Coins
-
February 2024 by James Cogan Jr.
Our Cogan family has been dealing with Sarasota rare coin for over 40 years. We trust them explicitly to be fair and give us guidance. I wouldn’t go anywhere else when it comes to coins and gold. Ben is always a pleasure to work with.
-
December 2023 by Juan Amesquita
don't go here I went to get some coins to get a price they where seal in a bag the guy that help me he open all the bags like he dint care and I ask what you doing and the price he give me dint convinced me after he opened the ones I have he put it in another bag with different coins I have there now I can't I event find the ones that they actually worth something thanks to this people
-
November 2023 by Steve Carey
Excellent buying/selling experience. Ryan was a wonderful host made me feel valued. Sold a worn $20 gold piece and got a fair price and the latest Redbook. Just be aware they pay with cheques that will cost you $5.00 to cash. But I'll be back as I spied a nice Silver dollar there amongst the hundreds rhey have on offer..
-
October 2023 by BlackBullEnt D.
I recently inherited my father's coin collection and got back into collecting. I wanted to make sure I was getting an authentic coin at market value. Sarasota Numismatics gave me great customer service and I received my commemorative coin in no time. It's hard getting good customer service nowadays but Sarasota Numismatics has a great staff for the job. Thanks Josh!
-
October 2023 by Kathleen Kuziel
I had inherited some coins from my parents years ago. I knew some of them were valuable but didn't know how to get a fair price for them. I saw an ad in the Observer for Eastern Numismatics and decided to try it out. The staff was wonderful!! I felt very comfortable and relaxed in dealing with both experts. My husband also brought some platinum he had. I had a good idea what my coin was worth a few years ago. But they valued it much higher than I expected. They also gave a very good price on the platinum. In a field where I don't know anything and expect to get fleeced, this was the most pleasant surprise. I plan to return to them to sell more coins and metals. I wouldn't mind buying some of their jewelry. I highly recommend this organization and the people that run it.
-
September 2023 by Terry G.
I have dealt with them for over 25 years.They have always had the very best inventory and the best service!Five stars all the way!
-
July 2023 by A. Saintango
Great NGC/PCGS authorized dealer. Purchased some certified coins through their eBay storefront and had a perfect experience. Prices were reasonable (even more so directly on their website), shipping was fast and secure. A+ all around.
-
June 2023 by James 1923
I've been a customer since 1984 the whole while being treated like their best one.Selling or buying, small amounts or large no matter. Always a fair deal, always great expertise given away free and always a good experience.
-
June 2023 by Jon Bradshaw
Very good selection to choose from if you want to pay way over spot. Very greedy operation going on here. This store is not looking for repeat customers. Rip off everyone once a make it. Go ahead and respond with whatever response you feel fits but..... Truth has been spoken on your level of greed!
-
May 2023 by Clay Smith
VERY PROFESSIONAL HONEST PEOPLE WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND THEM I WOULD NOT DEAL WITH ANYBODY ELSE THEY BEEN HERE FOR MANY YEARS GIVE GREAT ADVICE
-
May 2023 by John Smith
This guy is a rip off 5% over spot 1% under spot if selling. So I went in there recently and 2023 and now he has raised his silver bullion price $10 over spot which I didn’t realize that until the deal was done he didn’t tell me it’s $10 over spot.
-
March 2023 by joe goffart
This is one of the best coin shops that I've been to in My Life seriously I've been to hundreds of coin shops all over the country and these people are the best friendliest and nicest you could ever want in a coin shop!
-
March 2023 by Jon Kelly
I’ve been going here for many years. I stop in for unique gifts. They always have something cool. You can spend $20 or $20,000 and they treat you the same way. Not every shop is like that!
