Tuttle's Seahorse Shell Shop is a charming, locally owned gift shop located on Sanibel Island, beloved by visitors and residents alike. Known for its unique selection of nautical fine jewelry, beach-themed goods, and a variety of unexpected treasures, the shop offers items such as T-shirts, hats, shells, bracelets, toys, and games. Customers appreciate the inviting atmosphere, complete with pleasant music, which enhances the shopping experience. After being rebuilt following Hurricane Ian, Tuttle's has retained its old charm, making it a favorite stop for those on the island. The owner, Mr. Tuttle, is often described as kind and generous, creating a warm and welcoming environment for all who visit. Many customers have developed a kinship with him over the years and enjoy supporting this small business, understanding that prices may be slightly higher due to its unique offerings. With a history of over 50 years, Tuttle's Seahorse Shell Shop is highly recommended for anyone looking to find special gifts or unique items while enjoying the local atmosphere. Visitors are encouraged to take their time browsing through the delightful displays, ensuring a memorable shopping experience.
Beautiful, well designed nautical jewelry. Especially the sterling silver. Very unique charms and pendants. Bob behind the counter is incredibly kind. He has a rich history and tells a great story. Worth spending the time having a conversation with while you wait for your table next door.
October 2025
Absolutely the best shop on the island for gifts, personal treasures and souvenirs. My wife and I actually stopped in a second time because of their price, service and selection. Their nautical antiques and shell art stand out amongst the various shops on Sanibel. It is definitely worth a visit!!
August 2025
Loved visiting the shell fairy here! Such a great and fun environment!
