-
July 2024 by Michelle Zimmerman
Husband is a key lime pie connoisseur and he liked the Key Lime Pie Lady’s pie more than the one he got from the Blond Giraffe. The Trading Post is also a well stocked store with meats, wine, beer and gifts. I highly recommend the pre packaged pasta salad from the back cooler. I wish I had bought more than one!
-
June 2024 by Kj Johnson
We were in the keys and wanted to try the key lime pie. I had the pleasure of speaking with the maker of these delicious desserts. We picked some up and omg it was fantastic!! We were left wanting more. I don’t normally even like key lime desserts. I would highly recommend!!!
-
March 2024 by Chuck Thiel
Absolutely THE best Key lime pie I've ever eaten, period!
-
February 2024 by Maria Teresa Nappi
Local ranked the key lime pie lady inside of The Trading Post second only to his grandma. We concur! Perfect graham cracker (non-greasy) crust, excellent filling. Definitely a winner!
-
January 2024 by Ian
Great local staff.
-
January 2024 by Randy Ryder
The best key lime pie hands down
-
January 2024 by Ian Bellino
Great local staff.
-
January 2024 by Marc
5.0 Key lime Square! Pie is devine. Little grocery store. Go to back left cooler. I’m sure I’ll crave this rest of my life.
-
January 2024 by Kristi Zambrano
We tried 4 key lime pies while in the keys and this was by far the best!!! Afterwards, we wished we had only had this version as none of the others compared! Perfectly balanced sweet and tart, amazing crust. Absolutely delicious!!!
-
January 2024 by Frédérique Bouillet
Delicious pie, perfectly balanced between tangy key lime cream, crispy biscuit and cream. This recipe is rare and the fact of finding it in this small supermarket where the welcome from the charming ladies at the checkout is very warm, is a plus! THANKS
-
December 2023 by Jose G. Caimares
Open whenever you need it ??.
-
November 2023 by Katie K.
Love this little keys gem. The mini carts are my fav. Since I was a little girl it was always a fond memory. Also great way to support local businesses! Stop in, take your kids you wont regret it.
-
September 2023 by Danielle Vargas
Please do yourself a favor and try the key lime pie ice cream!!! Best ice cream I've ever had !
-
August 2023 by Ray Medrano
This is truly a hidden gem, the price is reasonable and they come frozen so you must let it thaw out. Great taste ?
-
May 2023 by Kara Strouse
I just bought a key lime pie bar and I couldn't even take a picture because... it was so good I got distracted and now it's gone. It was absolute perfection.
