The Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie Lady is a small, friendly store that offers a variety of groceries and delicious treats. It is well-known for its amazing key lime pie, which many customers describe as very good, refreshing, and perfectly balanced—neither too sweet nor too sour. The pies are available in full-sized, smaller, and individual slices, and are made by the Key Lime Lady, ensuring quality and authentic flavor. Customers also enjoy the store’s chocolate-dipped key lime pie slices and a tasty lemon bar. The pies are praised for being tangy, limey, and nicely sweetened, with some saying they are better than restaurant options and even blowing out well-known brands. The staff are friendly and helpful, making the shopping experience pleasant. Visitors often buy pies to take home, and some enjoy chatting with locals who share stories from the area. Overall, The Trading Post offers high-quality key lime pies and a welcoming atmosphere for those seeking a sweet taste of the local flavor.
Stopped by the Trading Post and grabbed a lemon bar by the cash register—absolutely amazing! Perfect balance of sweet and tangy with a buttery crust. Didn’t get to try the key lime pie, but if it’s anything like the lemon bar, it’s probably worth a taste next time.
November 2025
Amazing key lime pie!! In the frozen section, got a mini pie for myself and it defrosted by the time I was back in my hotel room. Delicious pie, beat any restaurant in town by far
August 2025
A little shop selling groceries and the key lime pie, which is one of the best tasting pies I've so far tried! Not overly sweet, tangy and limey. Delicious.
