-
March 2024 by Britt Z.
Their products are made with natural, locally sourced ingredients, and they don't use any chemicals, powder bases, additives, or preservatives. They have a great selection of gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan flavors. The store is very small and cramped, and all of the flavors are listed by category on the wall. Like most ice cream shops, there are no cases of ice cream to look at and choose, which I didn't like. Yes, you are offered samples, but with people behind you, do you really want to be "that person" who holds up the line? I know I don't. The guy working the counter was knowledgeable and friendly. I tried one sample of butterscotch brownie and ordered a small cup, which is still a lot of ice cream. They had a bench outside, but it was raining, so I ate in my car. The butterscotch and brownies are a good combination. The flavor was very good, but the ice cream itself is grainy. I didn't want to waste calories on something I didn't necessarily love, so I only ate a few spoonfuls. I was disappointed because I had heard such great things, but it just wasn't for me.
-
March 2024 by Courtney Ruedt
This is the BEST ice cream I’ve ever had in my life(chocolate honeycomb and key lime pie)Shout out Danny
-
February 2024 by Marni G.
BEST ICE CREAM SPOT IN BOCA!!! I love how they all the flavors are unique and they are all delicious m. My favorite is the cookie butter marshmallow it hits the spot everytime! The service is great there's only ever 1-2 people working there when I go. The ambiance is very trendy and calm. It's a small place so it's not like a dessert extravaganza.
-
February 2024 by Lori T.
Love, love, love, Proper Ice Cream! Such unique flavors. Took visiting family today and we had tasting plates plus a brownie sundae. A few of today's selections: Honeycomb chocolate, blueberry muffin, strawberry shortcake, cookie, butter marshmallow, strawberry mallow bar, Keylime pie with toasted meringue, olive oil, with butterscotch swirl, Dulce de Leche, deep chocolate, hazelnut. All super delicious. Handmade ice cream by people who love what they do!
-
February 2024 by Adrian Pritchard
Good ice cream. I had salted caramel and it was sweet and
-
January 2024 by James Scott
Sherbert was the beat if had in
-
January 2024 by Mathew A.
Proper Ice Cream was a nice little hole in the wall! I thoroughly enjoyed the creativity within the different ice cream flavors like the chocolate covered honeycomb and horchata which are flavors rarely seen, if ever. I think a pinch of salt to contrast the sweetness would help but overall the ice cream was good. If I could add an extra .5 star, I would for creativity alone. The staff was also very kind and accommodating and allowed us to try many different samples before picking on our flavor. Overall, I think the variety of flavors alone will bring me back, this is a good spot for a sweet treat !
-
January 2024 by Barbara Rosen
Delicious ice cream, nice people working there. Only take out , no seating.
-
December 2023 by Gladys M.
The ice cream we had was very grainy. It tasted like it was freezer burned. The waffle cone was barely filled to the top. Very disappointed
-
November 2023 by danny bonanno
Great experience and delicious ice cream .
-
October 2023 by D K
I think they served me overpriced old freezer burned ice cream. Not good as I expected ?
-
October 2023 by Twila M.
I used to love this place. Everything was fresh. The employees were very helpful in suggestions and giving you a sample taste. It made paying a kings ransom worth it. I stopped in today and had to pry out of the girl behind the counter what was in this and that.... She didn't offer me a taste sample. I had to ask. The deal of the day; buy 3 pints get one free. If she remotely did her job she could have easily sold me up on this deal. I asked her about the cookies.. again very lackadaisical. So I bought a pint of backyard mint and a chocolate chip cookie. I went to my car and I took a quick bite of the chocolate chip cookie that was disgustingly stale. Had to choke it down. I took it back into the store and informed her of the stale cookie. I didn't get a refund.. it's definitely not worth the big bucks they ask for this stuff!
-
September 2023 by Patrick O'Neill
Ice cream tucked away is a little strip mall. I ice cream was great, we got key lime pie and half baked. Only thing i would change was the spoon, don’t think they were made for ice cream….
-
September 2023 by Lona O'Connor
This is the real thing, just what you remember ice cream used to be! You'd fly by this tiny shop if you didn't know it was there. It's not cheap, not fast food, but definitely worth the price and the wait!
-
August 2023 by Barbara Olson
Absolutely outstanding. Better than the popular name brands… big names…must must try…
