-
September 2024 by Brittany Clifton
I sadly hate posting this review and 2 stars, because for years we have been wanting to try Star Fish Company and it was the biggest disappointment. We parked our boat, waited in line and then waited for an hour for food. The signs do say food takes a long time, so we were patient… however at an hour for waiting for a fish sandwich and fried shrimp, we said something. The server told us just a few more minutes. After 10 minutes, I said we were still waiting. After all the wait, we were then told there was a “problem in the kitchen” and it would be another 20-30 minutes for our food! Aka they lost the ticket or never made our order. We missed out on 1.5 hours of our rented boat time because of this. This is also not busy season and plenty of open tables. We sadly never got to try the food even though we heard it was wonderful. The atmosphere is neat and definitely check out their market to take fresh fish home. Just before you go check the wait and make sure you don’t have somewhere to be. ?
-
September 2024 by Angie Castro
Freshest fish sandwich you will ever have. Exclusive and known by the locals. Hidden gem. Would recommend. Very kind and attentive service. Had Grouper sandwiches. Worth the wait
-
September 2024 by David D.
This has got to be my favorite seafood red in Florida. The atmosphere is one of a kind and the food is absolutely amazing . I have been here many times and have left a happy man every time. I bring my friends from out of town here when they come visit. It is truly a unique Florida experience. The gulf seafood is cooked to perfection. One of my all time favorite restaurants.
-
September 2024 by Antonio Colon
Best and freshest seafood and fried fish I have ever tasted at a restaurant. Simply the best seafood in Tampa bay.
-
September 2024 by Danielle B.
We visited by boat last week + were impressed. We split a po boy, clam strips + hush puppies. Others in the party got the grouper nuggets and being from New England, I have a high bar for seafood. I would absolutely go back here again when in the area!
-
September 2024 by Matt Steiner
Great place to grab a fresh catch. Cool bar area that you can order up the days catches.
-
September 2024 by Matthew Post
Still the best seafood EVER
PLEASE SUPPORT THIS AMAZING PLACE FOREVER
-
September 2024 by MIke Jerkins
Best grouper sandwich in town!
-
September 2024 by RJ K
Star Fish serves great fresh seafood in a beautiful old Florida setting. All our meals were spot-on but the downside is it took about 20 minutes waiting in line to order and then another 30 minutes to get our food delivered to our table. And what's even worse is we waited in line, ordered (4 of us) and got 4 beers while placing the order. The beers are small and we wanted at least two more while waiting for our food but had to go back into a long line! A ridiculous way to operate a restaurant! Will not be returning.
-
September 2024 by Kellie Dinkelman
Food was great. Bring CASH!
-
September 2024 by Robert Glosson
Came all the way from Houston TX. Fried oysters were real greasy and I can't believe they charge 50 cents for tarter sauce in a seafood place. No more visits for me
-
September 2024 by isabel diaz
The food was excellent!! Fresh seafood. Will highly recommend!!
-
September 2024 by Kellie Weiss
Actually was just sitting and watching Debby getting fired up.
-
September 2024 by Angie Patterson
Great food and service as always!
-
September 2024 by Sydney Hiers
Super good and super fresh!