Star Fish Company is a casual seafood restaurant known for its fresh and delicious meals. Their Mahi Mahi is a standout dish, tender and flavorful. The coleslaw and hush puppies are also popular favorites. The relaxed atmosphere with picnic tables overlooking the water adds to the enjoyable dining experience. The combination platter and fried mullet are among the most requested options, featuring a light batter and generous portions. Customers praise the friendly service and cash-only policy, making this the perfect spot for a casual dinner. Recent reviews highlight the outstanding quality of the pompano fish, Atlantic salmon, and seafood salad sandwich, as well as the refreshing cold beer and scenic waterfront seating. The restaurant has a fresh fish market feel, with active fishermen coming in on the water and outdoor seating only. Diners order at the bar and wait for their names to be called for fresh hot food. The seating choices could be a challenge, with some areas in direct sun and others covered with fans. Customers also mention the limited seating and the need to arrive early to avoid a wait. Families enjoy the great food but should be cautious as the water is right next to the seating area. With a focus on fresh ingredients and a slower-paced celebration of life, Star Fish Company offers a memorable dining experience.
Best Stone Crab Chowder! Just drove an hour for this chowder. Love…..Love……Love!!! Here with family in our travels. Yeah!!
November 2025
The best place — we’ve come back year after year and it never disappoints. Truly the best and freshest fish on the island. We absolutely love the local vibe. This is a place you don’t want to miss!!!!
October 2025
Come fight off the seagulls and wild cat for your food. Friendly atmosphere just don't stand in the doorway the server's use just in front of the register window. Also the food was really good
